6 Manifolds with rough boundary
Manifolds with rough boundary, after [ GN26 , § 3.5 ] : the charts take values in locally convex subsets with dense interior of the model space, with the calculus of such sets developed in [ LCA ] . This includes manifolds with boundary and with corners. We prove that the boundary is well defined, and treat open subsets, graphs, subspaces and the tangent bundle.
6.1 Manifolds with rough boundary
Following [ GN26 , § 3.5 ] , manifolds may be modeled on subsets of \(E\) that are not open: a subset \(V \subseteq E\) is locally convex if every point of \(V\) has a convex neighborhood in \(V\), and it has dense interior if \(V \subseteq \overline{V^0}\). The \(C^{k}\) calculus of [ LCA ] ( [ GN26 , § 1.4 ] ) works on such sets: \(f\colon V \to F\) is \(C^{1}\) if it is continuous, \(C^{1}\) on \(V^0\), and \(\mathrm{d}(f|_{V^0})\) extends continuously to \(V \times E\). Below, \(r \in \mathbb {N}_0 \cup \{ \infty \} \) and “\(C^{r}\) on \(V\)” means \(C^{k}\) on \(V\) for every \(k \le r\). Mathlib’s charted spaces need open targets, so rough atlases are a separate structure, built on Mathlib’s partial homeomorphisms.
A rough \(E\)-chart of a topological space \(M\) is a homeomorphism \(\varphi \colon U_\varphi \to V_\varphi \) from an open subset of \(M\) onto a locally convex subset of \(E\) with dense interior. A \(C^{r}\) atlas of rough charts is a set \(\mathcal{A}\) of rough charts whose domains cover \(M\) and whose transition maps \(\psi \circ \varphi ^{-1}\colon \varphi (U_\varphi \cap U_\psi ) \to E\) are \(C^{r}\); for \(r = 0\) one requires moreover that \(\varphi (x) \in V_\varphi ^0\) if and only if \(\psi (x) \in V_\psi ^0\) [ GN26 , Definition 3.5.1(a), p. 278 ] .
The domains \(\varphi (U_\varphi \cap U_\psi )\) are relatively open in \(V_\varphi \), hence again locally convex with dense interior, so the \(C^{r}\) condition makes sense [ GN26 , Remark 3.5.2, p. 279 ] .
Let \(\varphi \), \(\psi \) be charts of a \(C^{r}\) atlas of rough charts at \(x \in M\). Then \(\varphi (x) \in V_\varphi ^0\) if and only if \(\psi (x) \in V_\psi ^0\) [ GN26 , Lemma 3.5.6, pp. 279–280 ] . Hence the boundary \(\partial M\), the set of points \(x\) with \(\varphi (x) \notin V_\varphi ^0\) for some chart \(\varphi \) at \(x\) [ GN26 , Definition 3.5.1(c), p. 278 ] , can be tested in any chart.
For \(r = 0\) this is an axiom. Let \(r \ge 1\), \(\kappa = \psi \circ \varphi ^{-1}\), \(y = \varphi (x) \in V_\varphi ^0\), and suppose \(z = \kappa (y)\) is not interior. Take an open \(W \ni z\) such that \(C = V_\psi \cap W\) is convex with nonempty interior. By Hahn–Banach there is \(\lambda \in E'\) with \(\lambda {\lt} \lambda (z)\) on \(C^0\), hence \(\lambda \le \lambda (z)\) on \(C\). Pick \(a \in C^0\) and \(v = z - a\), so \(\lambda (v) {\gt} 0\). The chain rule applied to \(\kappa \circ \kappa ^{-1} = \mathrm{id}\) at \(z\) gives \(u\) with \(\mathrm{d}\kappa (y, u) = v\). For \(t {\gt} 0\) small, \(\kappa (y + tu) \in C\), so \(t^{-1}(\lambda (\kappa (y + tu)) - \lambda (z)) \le 0\); these quotients converge to \(\lambda (v) {\gt} 0\), a contradiction.
For \(r = 0\) the axiom on interior points cannot be dropped in infinite dimensions: a closed ball of an infinite-dimensional Banach space is homeomorphic to the whole space [ GN26 , Remark 3.5.9, p. 280 ] . The proof above uses Hahn–Banach, hence the local convexity of \(E\) and of \(V_\psi \), but no completeness. The boundary \(\partial M\) is only a subset of \(M\); it need not be a submanifold (corners of \([0,1]^2\)), and no structure on it is constructed.
A \(C^{r}\) manifold with rough boundary is a topological space with a maximal \(C^{r}\) atlas of rough charts [ GN26 , Definition 3.5.1(b), p. 278 ] . Every rough atlas is contained in exactly one maximal atlas, the set of rough charts compatible with it, and the boundary does not change when the atlas is replaced by its maximal atlas.
The transition map between two charts compatible with \(\mathcal{A}\) factors, near each point, through a chart of \(\mathcal{A}\), and is \(C^{r}\) by the chain rule.
A map \(f\colon M \to N\) between manifolds with rough boundary is \(C^{s}\) if it is continuous and all its local representatives \(\psi \circ f \circ \varphi ^{-1}\colon \varphi (f^{-1}(U_\psi ) \cap U_\varphi ) \to F\) are \(C^{s}\) [ GN26 , Definition 3.5.11, p. 281 ] .
Compositions of \(C^{s}\) maps are \(C^{s}\) [ GN26 , Proposition 3.5.12, p. 281 ] . For \(s \le r\), a map is \(C^{s}\) for given atlases if and only if it is \(C^{s}\) for their maximal atlases.
Near a point, \(\psi \circ (g \circ f) \circ \varphi ^{-1} = (\psi \circ g \circ \kappa ^{-1}) \circ (\kappa \circ f \circ \varphi ^{-1})\) for a chart \(\kappa \) at the image point, and the chain rule on locally convex subsets with dense interior applies, since the domain of \(\psi \circ g \circ \kappa ^{-1}\) is relatively open in \(V_\kappa \). Chart independence follows by composing with the identity maps \((M, \mathcal{A}_{\max }) \to (M, \mathcal{A})\) and \((N, \mathcal{B}) \to (N, \mathcal{B}_{\max })\), which are \(C^{s}\) by definition of the maximal atlases.
A manifold modeled on \(E\) is a \(C^{r}\) manifold with rough boundary, for every \(r\), with empty boundary [ GN26 , Example 3.5.3(a), p. 279; Remark 3.5.7, p. 280 ] .
Products of \(C^{r}\) manifolds with rough boundary, with the product charts, are \(C^{r}\) manifolds with rough boundary [ GN26 , Example 3.5.5, p. 279 ] , and \(\partial (M \times N) = \partial M \times N \cup M \times \partial N\).
A nonempty locally convex subset \(U \subseteq E\) with dense interior, with the single chart \(U \hookrightarrow E\), is a \(C^{r}\) manifold with rough boundary, whose boundary is \(U \setminus U^0\) [ GN26 , Example 3.5.3(b), p. 279; Remark 3.5.7, p. 280 ] . This applies to convex sets with nonempty interior, such as closed half-spaces \(\{ \lambda \ge 0\} \), \(\lambda \ne 0\), and \([0, 1]\), whose boundary is \(\{ 0, 1\} \).
[ GN26 , Example 3.5.3(b) ] is stated for locally convex subsets with nonempty interior; the inclusion is a rough chart only if the interior is dense, which is what we assume. For convex sets the two conditions agree.
A nonempty open subset \(U\) of a \(C^{r}\) manifold with rough boundary \(M\) is one, with the restricted charts, and \(\partial U = U \cap \partial M\) [ GN26 , Example 3.5.4, p. 279 ] . A nonempty subset \(N \subseteq M\) such that every point of \(N\) has a chart \(\varphi \) with \(\varphi (U_\varphi \cap N)\) locally convex with dense interior (a full submanifold) is a \(C^{r}\) manifold with rough boundary, with \(\partial N = N \cap (\partial M \cup (N \setminus N^0))\) [ GN26 , Definition 3.5.19 and (3.24), p. 284 ] .
The targets of the restricted charts are relatively open in, or locally convex subsets with dense interior of, the targets of the charts of \(M\), and the transition maps are restrictions of those of \(M\). A point \(\varphi (x)\) is interior to \(\varphi (U_\varphi \cap N)\) if and only if it is interior to \(V_\varphi \) and \(x\) is interior to \(N\), which gives the boundary and condition (A3) for \(r = 0\).
Let \(F \subseteq E\) be a closed vector subspace. A subset \(N \subseteq M\) is a submanifold modeled on \(F\) if every point of \(N\) lies in a chart \(\varphi \) with \(\varphi (U_\varphi \cap N) = V_\varphi \cap F\) and \(V_\varphi \cap F\) with dense interior relative to \(F\) (S1), and, for \(r = 0\), adapted charts agree on boundary points (S2). The charts \(\varphi |_{U_\varphi \cap N}\) then form a \(C^{r}\) atlas of rough \(F\)-charts of \(N\) [ GN26 , Definition 3.5.14 and Remark 3.5.16, pp. 282–283 ] ; the transition maps are corestricted to \(F\) by [ GN26 , Lemma 1.4.16 ] .
Let \(M\) be a \(C^{r}\) manifold with rough boundary modeled on \(E\), \(N\) a \(C^{r}\) manifold without boundary modeled on \(F\), and \(f \colon M \to N\) a \(C^{r}\) map. Every point of the graph of \(f\) lies in a chart of \(M \times N\) adapted to the graph and to \(E \times \{ 0\} \); for \(r \geq 1\) the graph is a submanifold of \(M \times N\) modeled on \(E \times \{ 0\} \), with boundary \(\{ (x, f(x)) : x \in \partial M\} \) [ GN26 , Proposition 3.5.17, pp. 283–284 ] .
For charts \(\varphi \) of \(M\) and \(\psi \) of \(N\), the chart \(\theta (x, y) = (\varphi (x), \psi (y) - \psi (f(x)))\) is \(g \circ (\varphi \times \psi )\) for the \(C^{r}\) diffeomorphism \(g(z, w) = (z, w - h(z))\), \(h = \psi \circ f \circ \varphi ^{-1}\), so it is compatible with the product atlas. Its target is relatively open in \(\varphi (U_\varphi \cap f^{-1}(U_\psi )) \times F\), because \(\psi \) has open target, and it maps the graph onto \(E \times \{ 0\} \). For \(r = 0\), G–N obtain a submanifold with prescribed boundary [ GN26 , 3.5.15 ] , which we do not formalize.
A manifold with rough boundary modeled on \(\mathbb {R}^n\) is a manifold with corners (with boundary) if its maximal atlas contains charts around every point whose ranges are open subsets of \([0, \infty [^n\) (of \(\mathbb {R}^{n-1} \times [0, \infty [\)) [ GN26 , Remark 3.5.10, p. 281 ] . The quadrant itself is a manifold with corners, whose boundary is the set of points with a vanishing coordinate.
Let \(\mathcal{A}\) be a \(C^{r}\) atlas of rough charts of \(M\), \(r \ge 1\). The tangent bundle \(TM\) is glued from the sets \(V_\varphi \times E\), \(\varphi \in \mathcal{A}\), along the maps \(T(\psi \circ \varphi ^{-1})\colon (y, w) \mapsto (\psi \varphi ^{-1}(y), \mathrm{d}(\psi \circ \varphi ^{-1})(y, w))\); its tangent charts are \(T\varphi \colon TU_\varphi \to V_\varphi \times E\) [ GN26 , 3.5.22, p. 285; Definitions 3.3.5 and 3.3.7, p. 257 ] . In Lean, \(TM\) is the total space of a fiber bundle core over the chart domains, with fiber \(E\) and coordinate changes \(\mathrm{d}(\psi \circ \varphi ^{-1})(\varphi (x), \cdot )\).
At a boundary point \(x\), \(\mathrm{d}(\psi \circ \varphi ^{-1})(\varphi (x), \cdot )\) is the continuous extension of the differential from the interior, not a derivative at an interior point. It is nevertheless continuous linear [ GN26 , Lemma 1.4.7 ] and invertible, by the chain rule [ GN26 , Proposition 1.4.10 ] on the domains \(\varphi (U_\varphi \cap U_\psi )\), which are locally convex with dense interior. Hence each fiber, also over \(\partial M\), is a topological vector space isomorphic to \(E\) through every chart; it is all of \(E\), not a cone of inward vectors.
For \(r \ge 1\), the tangent charts form a \(C^{r-1}\) atlas of rough \(E \times E\)-charts of \(TM\), with transition maps \(T(\psi \circ \varphi ^{-1})\); the boundary of \(TM\) is \(\pi ^{-1}(\partial M)\), and \(\pi \colon TM \to M\) is \(C^{r-1}\) [ GN26 , 3.5.22, p. 285; Lemma 3.3.8, p. 258 ] .
The targets \(V_\varphi \times E\) are locally convex with dense interior. If \(g\) is \(C^{s}\) on \(D\), \(s \ge 1\), then \((y, w) \mapsto (g(y), \mathrm{d}g(y, w))\) is \(C^{s-1}\) on \(D \times E\) [ GN26 , Definition 3.3.3, p. 256 ] , since \(\mathrm{d}g\) is \(C^{s-1}\) and pairs of \(C^{s-1}\) maps are \(C^{s-1}\). As \((V_\varphi \times E)^0 = V_\varphi ^0 \times E\), interior points of \(TM\) are the vectors over interior points of \(M\), which gives the boundary of \(TM\) and, for \(r = 1\), the axiom on interior points.
Let \(f\colon M \to N\) be \(C^{s}\), \(s \ge 1\). The tangent map \(Tf\), given in tangent charts by \(T(\psi \circ f \circ \varphi ^{-1})\), does not depend on the charts and is \(C^{s-1}\); moreover \(T(\mathrm{id}) = \mathrm{id}\) and \(T(g \circ f) = Tg \circ Tf\) for \(C^{1}\) maps [ GN26 , Definition 3.3.11, p. 259; Proposition 3.3.12, p. 259; Remark 3.3.13, p. 260; 3.5.22, p. 285 ] . For ordinary manifolds the coordinate changes of \(TM\) are those of Definition 3.1.
For charts \(\varphi , \varphi '\) at \(x\) and \(\psi , \psi '\) at \(f(x)\), both \(\mathrm{d}(\psi ' \circ f \circ \varphi '^{-1})(\varphi '(x), \mathrm{d}(\varphi ' \circ \varphi ^{-1})(\varphi (x), v))\) and \(\mathrm{d}(\psi ' \circ \psi ^{-1})(\psi (f(x)), \mathrm{d}(\psi \circ f \circ \varphi ^{-1})(\varphi (x), v))\) are equal to \(\mathrm{d}(\psi ' \circ f \circ \varphi ^{-1})(\varphi (x), v)\), by the chain rule on the common domain \(\varphi (U_\varphi \cap U_{\varphi '} \cap f^{-1}(U_\psi \cap U_{\psi '}))\), which has dense interior; the differential on a smaller domain with dense interior is the restriction. The chain rule for \(T(g \circ f)\) is the same computation. We do not claim this argument is new.