12 Metric geometry
Metric spaces in which the distance is the infimum of lengths of curves, after Gromov, as in Chapter 8 of [ Lar26 ] : the rectifiable distance, interior metric spaces, approximate midpoints, the metric Hopf–Rinow theorem, and their asymmetric counterparts. The lengths of curves are those of Mathlib, through the variation of a curve. Nothing in this chapter uses manifolds or the calculus; it is applied to Finsler manifolds in Chapter 13.
12.1 The rectifiable distance
Let \((X, d)\) be a pseudo-metric space, with distances in \([0, \infty ]\). The length of a continuous curve \(\gamma \colon [a, b] \to X\) is the supremum of the sums \(\sum _i d(\gamma (t_i), \gamma (t_{i+1}))\) over the partitions of \([a, b]\); in Mathlib this is the variation eVariationOn. Its basic properties are in Mathlib: refining a partition increases the sums, the length vanishes only for constant curves, it is additive under concatenation, invariant under monotone reparametrizations [ Lar26 , Obs. 8.1.1 ] , lower semicontinuous under uniform convergence [ Lar26 , Prop. 8.1.3 ] , and the arc length \(t \mapsto \ell (\gamma |_{[a, t]})\) is continuous [ Lar26 , Lema 8.1.4 ] .
The rectifiable distance \(d_\ell (x, y)\) is the infimum of the lengths of the continuous curves from \(x\) to \(y\), and \(\infty \) if there is none.
\(d_\ell \) is a pseudo-distance, and \(d \leq d_\ell \). In particular the topology of \(d_\ell \) is finer than that of \(d\) [ Lar26 , Obs. 8.1.7 ] .
Constant curves, reversed curves and concatenations give the three properties of a distance. The trivial partition gives \(d(x, y) \leq \ell (\gamma )\).
The topologies of \(d\) and \(d_\ell \) coincide if and only if, for every \(x\) and every \(\varepsilon {\gt} 0\), the points close enough to \(x\) can be joined to \(x\) by curves of length \({\lt} \varepsilon \) [ Lar26 , Lema 8.1.8 ] .
This is the continuity of the identity \((X, d) \to (X, d_\ell )\), written with balls.
\((X, d)\) is an interior metric space (a length space) if \(d = d_\ell \) [ Lar26 , § 8.1.1 ] .
In an interior metric space, for all \(x, y\) and \(\varepsilon {\gt} 0\) there is \(z\) with \(\max \{ d(x, z), d(z, y)\} \leq \frac12 d(x, y) + \varepsilon \) [ Lar26 , Problema 8.III ] .
Take a curve of length \({\lt} d(x, y) + 2\varepsilon \). By the continuity of the arc length and the intermediate value theorem it has a point at half its length.
An interior metric space satisfies the ball condition: for \(r_1 + r_2 \leq d(x, y)\), the closed balls \(\bar B_{r_1}(x)\) and \(\bar B_{r_2}(y)\) are at distance at most \(d(x, y) - r_1 - r_2\). The ball condition is equivalent to having approximate midpoints, and a complete space with approximate midpoints is interior. So for complete spaces the three properties are equivalent.
The converse direction builds dyadic chains of approximate midpoints with steps at most \((d(x, y) + \varepsilon )/2^n\), and the curve as the uniform limit of the corresponding step functions, which exists by completeness and is \((d(x, y) + \varepsilon )\)-Lipschitz. This replaces the extension from dyadic rationals of [ Lar26 , Lema 8.1.9 ] .
12.2 The metric Hopf–Rinow theorem
In an interior metric space, for \(a, b \geq 0\) with \(a + b = d(x, y)\) and \(\varepsilon {\gt} 0\) there is \(z\) with \(d(x, z) \leq a + \varepsilon \) and \(d(z, y) \leq b + \varepsilon \).
As in Proposition 12.5, with the point at arc length \(a\).
A curve of finite length \(\ell \) can be reparametrized on \([0, 1]\) as an \(\ell \)-Lipschitz curve [ Lar26 , Obs. 8.1.5, Cor. 8.1.6 ] .
Compose with a right inverse of the normalized arc length; the curve is constant on the level sets of the arc length.
Let \(X\) be a complete interior metric space.
If \(\bar B_r(x)\) is compact for all \(0 {\lt} r {\lt} \rho \), then \(\bar B_\rho (x)\) is compact.
If \(X\) is locally compact, every closed ball is compact, and any two points are joined by a shortest curve, of length equal to their distance.
(1) By Lemma 12.7 every point of \(\bar B_\rho (x)\) is close to the compact ball \(\bar B_{\rho - \delta }(x)\), so \(\bar B_\rho (x)\) is totally bounded, and it is complete. (2) The supremum of the radii of compact balls cannot be finite: by (1) the ball of that radius is compact, and a finite cover by balls with compact closure, together with a Lebesgue number, gives a larger compact ball. For the shortest curves, reparametrize almost minimizing curves as in Lemma 12.8; they lie in a compact ball and are uniformly Lipschitz, and a cluster point in the product topology (Tychonoff) is a Lipschitz curve of length at most the distance. Here the formal proof departs from [ Lar26 ] , which uses Arzelà–Ascoli and the lower semicontinuity of the length.
\(\gamma \colon [0, 1] \to X\) is a short geodesic of length \(L\) if \(d(\gamma (s), \gamma (t)) = L |s - t|\); its length is \(L\). \(X\) is geodesic if it is interior and any two points are joined by a short geodesic [ Lar26 , Def. 8.1.11 ] .
Additivity of the length and the triangle inequality; for the normalization, the bounds \(d(\eta (s), \eta (t)) \leq L|s - t|\) and the triangle inequality through \(\eta (s), \eta (t)\) give the reverse inequality.
A space whose closed balls are compact is complete [ Lar26 , Obs. 8.2.4 ] . Being geodesic and locally compact does not imply completeness: the interval \((0, 1)\).
Let \(A\) be the diagonal operator on \(\ell ^2\) with \(a_0 = 1\), \(a_n = 1 + 2^{-n}\), and \(M = A(S)\), \(S\) the unit sphere, with lengths measured by the norm of \(\ell ^2\). Then the distance in \(M\) between \(e_0\) and \(-e_0\) is \(\pi \), but every piecewise \(C^{1}\) curve in \(M\) joining them is strictly longer than \(\pi \) [ Lar26 , Ejemplo 10.4.2 ] .
The curves \(A(\cos (\pi t) e_0 + \sin (\pi t) e_n)\) have length at most \(\pi a_n \to \pi \). Every curve on \(S\) from \(e_0\) to \(-e_0\) has length at least \(\pi \), by the triangle inequality for angles. If \(\beta = A\alpha \) is a curve in \(M\), \(\| \beta '\| = \| A\alpha '\| \geq \| \alpha '\| \), with equality only when \(\alpha ' \in \mathbb {R}e_0\), which forces \(\alpha \) to stay at \(e_0\).
In finite dimension this cannot happen: a complete Riemannian manifold has shortest curves [ Lar26 , Cor. 10.4.3 ] , and Corollary 13.55 gives the Finsler version.
12.3 Asymmetric distances
For a non-reversible Finsler structure \(d_b\) is not symmetric. Following Mennucci [ Men13 ] , an asymmetric distance \(b\) satisfies \(b(x, x) = 0\) and the triangle inequality, and the topology is that of the symmetrized distance \(\max \{ b(x, y), b(y, x)\} \); forward and backward balls alone may generate different topologies [ Men13 , Example 4.1 ] . Lengths are forward lengths: suprema of \(\sum b(\gamma (t_i), \gamma (t_{i+1}))\), which change under reversal of the curve [ Men13 , Remark 3.5 ] .
An asymmetric metric space carries \(b\) and the topology of its symmetrization. The forward length of a curve is its forward variation; \(b_\ell \) is the infimum of forward lengths of continuous curves, and \(X\) is forward interior if \(b_\ell = b\) (g-intrinsic in [ Men13 , Def. 3.16 ] ).
Forward lengths are additive and invariant under increasing reparametrizations; the running length of a continuous curve of finite forward length is continuous [ Men13 , Prop. 3.9 ] ; \(b \leq b_\ell \) and \(b_\ell \) satisfies the triangle inequality. Forward interior spaces have approximate intermediate points, and curves of finite forward length admit forward Lipschitz reparametrizations on \([0, 1]\).
The proofs of the symmetric case adapt, with care for the order of the arguments of \(b\); the continuity of the running length follows [ Men13 , Appendix B.2 ] .
Let \(X\) be a Hausdorff forward interior space, \(b(x, y) {\lt} \infty \), with compact closed forward ball \(\{ z : b(x, z) \leq b(x, y) + 1\} \) on which \(b(w, z) \leq C\, b(z, w)\). Then there is a continuous curve from \(x\) to \(y\) of forward length \(b(x, y)\).
For any Finsler length structure, \(\ell ^+(\gamma ) \leq L_b(\gamma )\) and \((M, d_b)\) is forward interior. A reversibility constant \(\mu _x(-v) \leq \lambda \mu _x(v)\) gives \(d_b(y, x) \leq \lambda d_b(x, y)\); if moreover \(\mu \) is bounded below and the closed forward ball is compact, there are shortest forward curves.
\(\mu _s(v) = \mu (v) + \mu (-v)\) is a reversible Finsler length structure, and \(\max \{ d_b(x, y), d_b(y, x)\} \leq d_s(x, y)\). With a reversibility constant \(\lambda \), \(d_s \leq (1 + \lambda ) d_b\), and the identity is a homeomorphism between \((M, d_b)\) and \((M, d_s)\).
Pointwise comparisons of the integrands pass to lengths of chains and to distances.
So for the topology, bounded asymmetry reduces to the reversible case; lengths and shortest curves of \(d_b\) and \(d_s\) are, however, different, and without a reversibility constant the topology of \(d_s\) may be strictly finer.