Manifolds modeled on locally convex spaces

15 Analytic manifolds

Real and complex analytic manifolds modeled on locally convex spaces, following [ GN26 , Definitions 3.1.3–3.1.4 and 2.2.18 ] . Real analyticity is Milnor’s notion: a map is real analytic if it extends to a complex analytic map on an open subset of the complexification \(E_{\mathbb {C}} = E \times E\) (see the companion library lc-analysis). As for smooth manifolds, no completeness of the model space is assumed: composition, locality, “analytic implies smooth” and “complex analytic implies real analytic” hold for arbitrary Hausdorff locally convex spaces.

15.1 The analytic groupoids

For a real locally convex space \(E\), the real analytic groupoid consists of the homeomorphisms between open subsets of \(E\) which are real analytic, with real analytic inverse. For a complex locally convex space \(E\), the complex analytic groupoid is defined in the same way with complex analytic maps.

Proof ▶

These are structure groupoids: compositions of real (complex) analytic maps are real (complex) analytic [ GN26 , Proposition 2.2.4 ] , and real (complex) analyticity is a local property [ GN26 , Lemma 2.2.3 ] .

Every real analytic diffeomorphism is a smooth diffeomorphism, and (for a complex locally convex space) every complex analytic diffeomorphism is real analytic.

Proof ▶

Real analytic maps are smooth [ GN26 , Lemma 2.2.5 ] ; complex analytic maps are real analytic [ GN26 , Proposition 2.2.11 ] . Neither statement uses completeness.

A real (complex) analytic manifold is a charted space whose transition maps belong to the real (complex) analytic groupoid. By Proposition 15.2, a complex analytic manifold is real analytic, and a real analytic manifold is smooth.

Remark 15.4
#

Both groupoids are closed under restriction to open sets, so open subsets of analytic manifolds (in particular of the model space) are analytic manifolds [ GN26 , Examples 3.1.8 and 3.1.9 ] .

15.2 Analytic maps

A map \(f \colon M \to N\) is real (complex) analytic on an open set \(U \subseteq M\) if it is continuous on \(U\) and its local representatives in the preferred charts are real (complex) analytic.

Lemma 15.6 Insertion of charts
✓

Near each point of the domain of \(e' \circ f \circ e^{-1}\), this map factors as \((e' \circ c'^{-1}) \circ (c' \circ f \circ c^{-1}) \circ (c \circ e^{-1})\) with explicit open domains, for any other charts \(c\), \(c'\) [ GN26 , Remark 3.1.5 ] .

Proof ▶

Set theory.

Proof ▶

Insert charts (Lemma 15.6) and use that the classes of analytic maps are closed under composition and local.

Example 15.8 Inversion in a continuous inverse algebra
✓
#

The unit group \(A^\times \) of a real continuous inverse algebra \(A\) is open in \(A\), hence a real analytic manifold, and inversion is real analytic on it [ GN26 , Proposition 2.2.13 ] .

15.3 Complexifications

Definition 15.9 Complexification
✓

A complex analytic manifold \(M^*\) modeled on \(E_{\mathbb {C}}\) is a complexification of a real analytic manifold \(M\) modeled on \(E\) if \(M \subseteq M^*\) and each \(x \in M\) lies in the domain \(U^*\) of a chart \(\varphi \colon U^* \to U'\) of \(M^*\) with \(\varphi (M \cap U^*) = E \cap U'\) such that \(\varphi |_{M \cap U^*}\) is a chart of \(M\) [ GN26 , Definition 2.2.18 ] . In Lean the inclusion is an injective map \(\iota \colon M \to M^*\). The space \(E_{\mathbb {C}}\) is a complexification of \(E\).

Lemma 15.10 Gluing near a closed set [ GN26 , Lemma A.5.10 ]
✓

Let \(Z\) be paracompact, \(A \subseteq Z\) closed, \((V_i)\) open sets covering \(A\), and \(g_i\) maps such that \(g_i\) and \(g_j\) agree near each point of \(A \cap V_i \cap V_j\). Then there are an open \(U \supseteq A\) and a map \(g\) which near each point of \(U\) agrees with some \(g_i\) on an open subset of \(V_i\).

Proof ▶

As in [ GN26 ] : closed neighborhoods \(Q_z \subseteq V_{i(z)}\) of the points of \(A\), a locally finite open refinement \((W_j)\) of the cover by their interiors and \(Z \setminus A\), and around each \(a \in A\) a neighborhood meeting finitely many \(W_j\), avoiding the closures of those not containing \(a\) in their closure, and contained in the sets where the corresponding \(g_i\) agree.

Let \(M^*\) be a complexification of the real analytic manifold \(M\), with \(M\) closed in \(M^*\) and \(M^*\) paracompact. Every real analytic map from \(M\) to a complex analytic manifold \(L\) extends to a complex analytic map on an open neighbourhood of \(M\) in \(M^*\).

Proof ▶

In a chart \(\varphi \) of \(M^*\) restricting to a chart \(\psi \) of \(M\) and a chart \(\kappa \) of \(L\), the local representative \(\kappa \circ f \circ \psi ^{-1}\) has a complex analytic extension, which after shrinking has real points only where \(f\) is defined in these charts; this gives local extensions \(g_x\). Two of them agree near each point of \(M\): on a convex neighbourhood in \(E_{\mathbb {C}}\) their representatives agree on the real points, hence everywhere by the identity theorem. Lemma 15.10 glues them.

15.4 Real analytic forms

Let \(M\) be a real analytic manifold. A form \(\omega \in \Omega ^n(M, F)\) is real analytic if its local representatives (Definition 8.7) are real analytic in the sense of Milnor [ GN26 , Remark 3.6.18 ] . The real analytic forms are a subspace \(\Omega ^n_\omega (M, F)\) of \(\Omega ^n(M, F)\). A smooth vector field is real analytic if its local representatives are.

Exterior derivatives, compositions with continuous linear maps, wedge products and pullbacks along real analytic maps of real analytic forms are real analytic. Brackets of real analytic vector fields are real analytic, and so are \(i_X\omega \) and \(L_X\omega \) for real analytic \(X\) and \(\omega \). Hence all the identities of Section 8.6 hold in \(\Omega ^\bullet _\omega (M, F)\), as asserted in [ GN26 , Remark 3.6.18 ] .

Proof ▶

In a chart, each operation is built from the local representatives by sums, compositions with continuous (multi)linear maps, compositions with real analytic maps and directional derivatives. Real analytic maps are closed under all of these, the last one because if \(g\) is a complex analytic extension of \(f\), then \(\mathrm{d}g\), read on \((E \times E)_{\mathbb {C}} \cong E_{\mathbb {C}} \times E_{\mathbb {C}}\), is a complex analytic extension of \(\mathrm{d}f\) (LocallyConvex.Analysis.RealAnalyticOn.dMB in lc-analysis). For pullbacks, real analyticity is local [ GN26 , Lemma 2.2.3 ] , and near each point the representative of \(\varphi ^*\omega \) is a local pullback along a real analytic map between chart domains.

Let \(Z^n_\omega (M, F)\) be the closed real analytic \(n\)-forms and \(B^n_\omega (M, F) = \mathrm{d}(\Omega ^{n-1}_\omega (M, F))\), with \(B^0_\omega = 0\). The real analytic de Rham cohomology is \(H^n_\omega (M, F) = Z^n_\omega (M, F)/B^n_\omega (M, F)\), and there is a natural linear map \(H^n_\omega (M, F) \to H^n_{dR}(M, F)\).

Remark 15.15
#

For a real analytic submanifold \(V\) of \(\mathbb {R}^n\) this map is an isomorphism [ Car57 , § 7, consequence (4), p. 89 ] , a consequence of Cartan’s Theorem B for coherent analytic sheaves on analytic subsets of \(\mathbb {R}^n\) [ Car57 , Theorem 3 ] ; the proof is omitted there. This covers every second countable real analytic manifold, since such a manifold admits a real analytic, regular and proper embedding into some \(\mathbb {R}^k\) [ Gra58 , Theorem 3, p. 470 ] . The proof uses complexifications and sheaf cohomology on Stein manifolds, with no counterpart for general locally convex models. We do not know whether it is injective or surjective in general.

Remark 15.16 What is not covered
#

The following parts of [ GN26 , Section 3.6 ] are not formalized.

  • The finite-dimensional material (Definition 3.6.19 to Remark 3.6.24: forms on subsets of \(\mathbb {R}^n\), orientations, integration of forms and Stokes’ Theorem).