18 Examples
In this chapter we test the general notions of the previous chapters on concrete examples: closed subspaces, open subsets, graphs, the unit sphere of an inner product space and the unitary group of a Banach \(*\)-algebra. They show that embedded and split submanifolds, fields of projectors and their geodesics behave as expected; in all of them the slice charts are explicit, so that no inverse function theorem is needed. The last section prepares the ground for groups of diffeomorphisms: we construct the Fréchet space \(C^\infty _{per}\) of smooth periodic functions and identify the universal cover of \(\operatorname {Diff}^+(S^1)\) with an open convex subset of it.
Throughout, we keep track of completeness. A model space is a real locally convex Hausdorff space, not necessarily complete; when an example is a Banach, Hilbert or Fréchet manifold we say so, and we say where completeness is used.
18.1 Closed subspaces, open subsets and graphs
The simplest submanifolds are linear. Let \(F\) be a locally convex space and \(S \subseteq F\) a linear subspace.
If \(S\) is closed, then \(S\) is an embedded submanifold of \(F\) modeled on \(S\), with the identity of \(F\) as slice chart at every point, and \(T_pS = S\) for every \(p \in S\). If \(S\) is complemented, \(S\) is a split submanifold.
The identity belongs to the maximal atlas of \(F\), and \(q \in S\) if and only if \(\mathrm{id}(q) \in S\). The differential of the identity is the identity, so the tangent space read in this chart is \(S\).
If \(S\) is closed, the inclusion \(\iota \colon S \to F\) is an immersion. It is a split immersion if and only if \(S\) is complemented in \(F\).
In the identity charts the differential of \(\iota \) at every point is \(\iota \) itself, which is a topological isomorphism onto the closed subspace \(S\). A continuous left inverse of \(\iota \) is the same thing as a continuous projection of \(F\) onto \(S\).
A continuous projection \(P\) of \(F\) onto \(S\) (\(P^2 = P\), \(\operatorname {ran} P = S\)) gives the simplest field of projectors: the constant one.
Let \(S\) be closed and \(P\) a continuous projection onto \(S\). Then \(E_p = P\) for all \(p \in S\) is a field of projectors, the symbols of its connection vanish in the identity chart, and a \(C^{2}\) curve \(\alpha \) in \(S\) is a geodesic if and only if \(\ddot\alpha (t) = 0\) for all \(t\).
Smoothness of \((p, w) \mapsto P w\) is that of a continuous linear map. The symbols involve the second differential of the inclusion, which is zero. For the geodesics, the general criterion says that \(\alpha \) is a geodesic iff \(P\ddot\alpha = 0\); since \(\ddot\alpha \) takes values in \(S\) and \(P\) is the identity on \(S\), this is \(\ddot\alpha = 0\).
So the connection is flat and its geodesics are the curves of zero acceleration, that is, the affine lines \(t \mapsto x + t v\) (this last reformulation is the usual one and is not stated separately in Lean).
An open subset \(U\) of a manifold \(M\) modeled on \(E\) is an embedded submanifold of \(M\), modeled on the whole space \(E\).
The restriction of the chart at \(p\) to \(U\) is again a chart (the Michal–Bastiani groupoid is closed under restriction to open sets), and every point of its domain lies in \(U\).
Let now \(E, G\) be locally convex spaces, \(U \subseteq E\) open and \(g \colon U \to G\) smooth. The graph of \(g\) is
and its model is the horizontal subspace \(E \times 0\), the kernel of the second projection.
The map \(\Phi (x, y) = (x, y - g(x))\), defined on \(U \times G\), is a chart of \(E \times G\) with inverse \(\Phi ^{-1}(x, z) = (x, z + g(x))\), and \((x, y) \in \Gamma _g\) if and only if \(\Phi (x, y) \in E \times 0\). Hence \(\Gamma _g\) is a split submanifold of \(E \times G\) modeled on \(E \times 0\).
Both \(\Phi \) and \(\Phi ^{-1}\) are built from \(g\), projections and sums, hence they are smooth on \(U \times G\). The subspace \(E \times 0\) is closed and complemented by \(0 \times G\), with projection \((x, y) \mapsto (x, 0)\).
In finite dimensions one usually proves that graphs (and level sets of submersions) are submanifolds through the inverse function theorem. That theorem is not available for Michal–Bastiani maps between locally convex spaces, and it is not needed here: the chart \(\Phi \) and its inverse are written down explicitly. The same strategy is used for the sphere and the unitary group below.
18.2 The unit sphere of an inner product space
Let \(H\) be a real inner product space and \(e \in H\) a unit vector. We write \(e^\perp = \{ w : \langle w, e\rangle = 0\} \), a closed subspace of \(H\), and \(S = \{ q \in H : \| q\| = 1\} \).
We do not assume that \(H\) is complete. If \(H\) is complete, \(H\) is a Hilbert manifold and \(S\) is a Hilbert submanifold. If \(H\) is not complete, \(H\) is still a manifold in our sense (model spaces need not be complete), but neither \(H\) nor \(S\) is a Hilbert or Banach manifold. The construction below does not use completeness, so it covers both cases; the statements about Hilbert manifolds are the case of a complete \(H\).
On the open hemisphere around \(e\) we use the explicit chart
defined on \(\{ q : \| q - \langle q, e\rangle e\| {\lt} 1,\ \langle q, e\rangle {\gt} 0\} \). By Pythagoras, \(\| q\| ^2 = \| q - \langle q, e\rangle e\| ^2 + \langle q, e\rangle ^2\), so on this set \(\| q\| = 1\) exactly when the height \(\sqrt{1 - \| q - \langle q,e\rangle e\| ^2}\) equals \(\langle q, e\rangle \), that is, when \(\varphi _e(q) \in e^\perp \). At another point \(p \in S\) we first apply the Householder reflection \(R_p\) exchanging \(p\) and \(e\) (the reflection across \((p - e)^\perp \)), a linear isometry, and then \(\varphi _e\).
The map \(\varphi _e\) is a smooth chart of \(H\) with smooth inverse; for \(q\) in its domain, \(\| q\| = 1\) if and only if \(\varphi _e(q) \in e^\perp \). For every unit vector \(p\), the chart \(\varphi _e \circ R_p\) is smooth and its domain contains \(p\).
The square root is smooth where its argument is positive, and the remaining operations are continuous linear or bilinear; Fréchet smoothness implies Michal–Bastiani smoothness. The identity \(\varphi _e^{-1}\varphi _e = \mathrm{id}\) holds because the component of \(q\) orthogonal to \(e\), and hence the height, does not change when we add a multiple of \(e\). The equivalence is Pythagoras, and \(R_p p = e\) lies in the domain of \(\varphi _e\).
The unit sphere \(S\) is an embedded submanifold of \(H\) modeled on \(e^\perp \), and \(T_pS = p^\perp \) for every \(p \in S\).
Since \(R_p\) is an isometry, \(\| q\| = 1\) iff \(\| R_p q\| = 1\) iff \(\varphi _e(R_p q) \in e^\perp \). At \(e\) the height has zero derivative, so \(\mathrm{d}\varphi _e(e) = \mathrm{id}\), and by the chain rule \(\mathrm{d}(\varphi _e \circ R_p)(p) = R_p\). Then \(w \in T_pS\) iff \(\langle e, R_p w\rangle = 0\) iff \(\langle R_p p, R_p w\rangle = 0\) iff \(\langle p, w\rangle = 0\).
The orthogonal projections onto the tangent spaces give a field of projectors, and the geodesics of its connection are the curves whose acceleration is normal to the sphere.
The maps \(E_p w = w - \langle w, p\rangle p\), \(p \in S\), form a field of projectors onto the tangent spaces of \(S\). A curve \(\alpha \) in \(S\) whose ambient curve is smooth is a geodesic of the associated connection if and only if
In particular, if \(p, v \in H\) are unit vectors with \(\langle p, v\rangle = 0\), the great circle \(t \mapsto \cos t\, p + \sin t\, v\) is a geodesic.
It is immediate that \(E_p\) is linear, idempotent, with range \(p^\perp \). In a slice chart, \((x, w) \mapsto E_{\psi (x)} w\) is smooth because the parametrization \(\psi \) is. By the general criterion, \(\alpha \) is a geodesic iff \(E_{\alpha (t)}\ddot\alpha (t) = 0\), which is the stated equation. For the great circle, \(\ddot\alpha = -\alpha \) and \(\| \alpha \| = 1\).
The radial projection \(\Sigma (p, w) = (p + w)/\| p + w\| \), \(w \perp p\), is a normalized local addition on \(S\), defined on all of \(TS\). The map \(\theta = (\pi , \Sigma )\) sends \(TS\) onto \(\{ (p, q) \in S \times S : \langle p, q\rangle {\gt} 0\} \), with inverse \((p, q) \mapsto (p, q/\langle p, q\rangle - p)\). No completeness is assumed.
Apply Proposition 14.6 with \(\sigma (p, w) = (p + w)/\| p + w\| \) on \(p + w \neq 0\) and \(\tau (p, q) = q/\langle p, q\rangle - p\) on \(\langle p, q\rangle {\gt} 0\), both smooth in the Fréchet sense, hence in the sense of Michal–Bastiani. For \(\| p\| = 1\) and \(w \perp p\), \(\langle p, \sigma (p, w)\rangle = \| p + w\| ^{-1} {\gt} 0\) and \(\tau (p, \sigma (p, w)) = w\); conversely \(\tau (p, q) \perp p\) and \(\sigma (p, \tau (p, q)) = q\). The derivative of \(t \mapsto \sigma (p, tw)\) at \(0\) is \(w - \langle p, w\rangle p = w\). Glöckner and Neeb do not treat the sphere; we do not claim this construction is new.
Let \(H\) be a real inner product space, not necessarily complete, and \(e \in H\) a unit vector. The unit sphere \(S\) is a split real analytic submanifold of \(H\) modeled on \(e^\perp \), hence a real analytic manifold, and the radial projection \(\Sigma (p, w) = (p + w)/\| p + w\| \) of Theorem 18.11 is a real analytic local addition on it [ GN26 , p. 325 ] .
The inner product is a continuous bilinear form, hence real analytic; its complexification is the complex bilinear (not sesquilinear) extension to \(H_{\mathbb {C}} \times H_{\mathbb {C}}\). The functions \(t \mapsto \sqrt t\) on \(t {\gt} 0\) and \(t \mapsto t^{-1}\) on \(t \neq 0\) extend holomorphically to the slit plane and to \(\mathbb {C} \setminus \{ 0\} \). The norm is used only as \(\| x\| = \sqrt{\langle x, x\rangle }\) on \(x \neq 0\). So \(\sigma \), \(\tau \) and the charts of the sphere (built from the height \(\sqrt{1 - \| q'\| ^2}\), with \(q'\) the component of \(q\) in \(e^\perp \), and from Householder reflections) are real analytic, the model \(e^\perp \) is complemented by the orthogonal projection, and Proposition 14.15 applies. Normalization of the real analytic local addition is not proved; for the smooth structure it is Theorem 18.11. Glöckner and Neeb do not treat the sphere; we do not claim this construction is new.
18.3 The unitary group of a Banach \(*\)-algebra
Let \(A\) be a real Banach algebra with a continuous involution \(a \mapsto a^*\) (in Lean: a complete normed \(\mathbb {R}\)-algebra which is a \(*\)-ring and a \(*\)-module, with continuous \(*\)). For instance \(A = B(H)\), the bounded operators on a complex Hilbert space \(H\), seen as a real algebra. The unitary group is
and its model is the space \(\mathfrak u(A) = \{ X \in A : X^* = -X\} \) of skew-adjoint elements.
Here \(A\) is complete, so \(A\) is a Banach manifold and \(U(A)\) is a Banach submanifold of it. Completeness is used twice: the invertible elements form an open set, and inversion is smooth on it. Both facts may fail in an incomplete normed algebra.
The slice charts are Cayley transforms. On the open set \(\{ a : a + 1 \text{ invertible}\} \) we let
At other points \(p \in U(A)\) we compose with the left translation \(a \mapsto p^* a\), a linear homeomorphism of \(A\) with inverse \(a \mapsto pa\).
The Cayley transform \(\varphi \) is a smooth chart of \(A\) with smooth inverse. If \(a + 1\) is invertible, then \(a \in U(A)\) if and only if \(\varphi (a) \in \mathfrak u(A)\). For every \(p \in U(A)\), the chart \(a \mapsto \varphi (p^* a)\) is a slice chart for \(U(A)\) around \(p\).
The inverse of \(\varphi \) is checked by a direct computation with units, and smoothness follows from the smoothness of inversion on the open set of units. The equivalence is pure algebra: writing \(s = a + 1\) and using \((s^{-1})^* = (s^*)^{-1}\), the condition \(\varphi (a)^* = -\varphi (a)\) unwinds to \(a^* a = 1 = a a^*\); no spectral theory is needed. Finally \(p^* p + 1 = 2\) is invertible, so \(p\) lies in the domain of the translated chart.
The unitary group \(U(A)\) is a split submanifold of \(A\) modeled on \(\mathfrak u(A)\), and
In particular this holds for the unitary group of \(B(H)\), \(H\) a complex Hilbert space.
The skew-adjoint elements are closed and complemented by the self-adjoint ones, with projection \(X \mapsto (X - X^*)/2\). The derivative of \(\varphi \) at \(1\) is \(w \mapsto w/2\), so the derivative of the translated chart at \(p\) is \(w \mapsto p^* w/2\), and the tangent space is read off as in Theorem 18.9.
The natural projector onto \(T_pU(A)\) is \(E_p w = \tfrac 12(w - p w^* p)\); writing \(X = p^* w\), it is \(E_p w = p\, \tfrac 12(X - X^*)\), the skew-adjoint part translated back to \(p\).
The maps \(E_p w = \tfrac 12(w - p w^* p)\), \(p \in U(A)\), form a field of projectors onto the tangent spaces of \(U(A)\). A curve \(\alpha \) in \(U(A)\) whose ambient curve is smooth is a geodesic of the associated connection if and only if
For \(p \in U(A)\) and \(X \in \mathfrak u(A)\), the curve \(t \mapsto p\, e^{tX}\) is a geodesic.
Using \(p^*p = 1 = pp^*\) one checks \(p (E_p w)^* p = \tfrac 12(p w^* p - w)\), whence \(E_p^2 = E_p\), and \(p^* E_p w = \tfrac 12(p^* w - w^* p)\) is skew-adjoint. The geodesic equation is the general criterion \(E_{\alpha }\ddot\alpha = 0\). For \(\alpha (t) = p e^{tX}\), \(e^{tX}\) is unitary and commutes with \(X\), and \(\ddot\alpha = p e^{tX}X^2\); a short computation gives \(\alpha \ddot\alpha ^*\alpha = p e^{tX} X^2\).
The structure of Lie group of \(U(A)\) (smoothness of the product and of the inversion in these charts) is not addressed in this chapter; we only use \(U(A)\) as a submanifold of \(A\). The connection of Theorem 18.16 is defined directly from the field of projectors, with no metric behind it. The header of the Lean file also mentions \(B(H)\) for a real Hilbert space \(H\); the formalized statement isSplitSubmanifold_unitary_clm covers complex Hilbert spaces.
18.4 Smooth periodic functions and \(\operatorname {Diff}^+(S^1)\)
18.4.1 The Fréchet space \(C^\infty _{per}\)
Let \(C^\infty _{per}\) be the space of smooth \(1\)-periodic functions \(u \colon \mathbb {R}\to \mathbb {R}\) (smooth functions on the circle \(S^1 = \mathbb {R}/\mathbb Z\)), with the topology of uniform convergence of all the derivatives, that is, the topology of the seminorms
The topology and the uniform structure of \(C^\infty _{per}\) are those induced by the injective linear map
into a countable product of Banach spaces of bounded continuous functions. The seminorm \(p_k\) is the sup norm of the \(k\)-th component of \(J\).
All the structure is inherited from the product: \(C^\infty _{per}\) is a Hausdorff locally convex topological vector space, and it is metrizable, since the product is countable. In Lean these are instances on CInfPer.
A net \(u_i\) converges to \(u\) in \(C^\infty _{per}\) if and only if \(u_i^{(k)} \to u^{(k)}\) uniformly on \(\mathbb {R}\) for every \(k\). Moreover \(p_k(u) \le C\) if and only if \(|u^{(k)}(x)| \le C\) for all \(x\).
\(J\) is a uniform embedding and convergence in a product is convergence of every component.
The range of \(J\) is closed. Consequently \(C^\infty _{per}\) is complete, and it is a Fréchet space: locally convex, Hausdorff, metrizable and complete.
If \(u_n^{(k)} \to g_k\) uniformly for every \(k\), the theorem on uniform limits of derivatives shows that \(g_0\) is differentiable with \(g_0' = g_1\), and inductively \(g_0^{(k)} = g_k\); so \(g_0\) is smooth, periodic, and \(J(g_0) = (g_k)_k\). A closed subspace of the complete space \(\prod _k BC(\mathbb {R})\) is complete, and \(J\) is a uniform embedding.
The space \(C^\infty _{per}\) is not normable, so it is a Fréchet space that is not a Banach space. Non-normability is the standard fact that a normable Fréchet space has a bounded neighbourhood of \(0\); it is not formalized here. Completeness, which we do prove, is what makes the manifolds modeled on \(C^\infty _{per}\) below Fréchet manifolds in the strict sense.
18.4.2 The universal cover of \(\operatorname {Diff}^+(S^1)\)
Let \(\pi \colon \mathbb {R}\to S^1 = \mathbb {R}/\mathbb Z\) be the projection. We recall the classical facts that relate circle maps to their lifts; they are not formalized, and the formalization works directly with the lifts.
The map \(\pi \) is a covering map and a local diffeomorphism.
Existence and uniqueness of lifts. Since \(\mathbb {R}\) is simply connected, every continuous \(f \colon S^1 \to S^1\) has a continuous lift \(\varphi \colon \mathbb {R}\to \mathbb {R}\), \(\pi \circ \varphi = f \circ \pi \), by the lifting criterion [ Hat02 , § 1.3, Prop. 1.33 ] (see also the homotopy lifting property, [ Hat02 , Prop. 1.30 ] ), and two lifts differ by an integer constant: integer translations are deck transformations, and a lift is determined by its value at one point [ Hat02 , Prop. 1.34 ] .
Degree. \(\varphi (x + 1) - \varphi (x)\) is a continuous integer valued function, hence a constant \(d\), the degree of \(f\) [ KH95 , Lemma 2.4.3, Def. 2.4.4 ] . A homeomorphism has degree \(\pm 1\) (the degree is multiplicative, [ KH95 , Prop. 8.2.2 ] ), and it preserves the orientation exactly when \(d = 1\) [ KH95 , § 11.1, p. 388 ] , i.e. \(\varphi (x + 1) = \varphi (x) + 1\); then \(\varphi = \mathrm{id}+ u\) with \(u\) \(1\)-periodic.
Smoothness. Since \(\pi \) is a local diffeomorphism, \(\varphi \) is smooth if and only if \(f\) is, and \(\varphi \) is a diffeomorphism of \(\mathbb {R}\) exactly when \(f\) is a diffeomorphism of \(S^1\) (the inverse of \(f\) lifts to the inverse of \(\varphi \)).
So \(\operatorname {Diff}^+(S^1) \cong \Omega /\mathbb Z\), where \(n \in \mathbb Z\) acts by \(u \mapsto u + n\) and \(\Omega \) is the set defined below. This is the description of Herman [ Her79 , Ch. I, 1.7 ] , where \(D^r(T^1) = \{ \mathrm{id}+ \varphi \} \) is called the universal cover of \(\operatorname {Diff}^r_+(T^1)\); Hamilton [ Ham82 , Part I, Example 4.2.6 ] parametrizes \(\operatorname {Diff}^+(S^1)\) instead by \(S^1 \times \{ f' {\gt} 0,\ \int f' = 2\pi \} \). Since \(\Omega \) is convex, hence contractible, \(\Omega \to \operatorname {Diff}^+(S^1)\) is the universal cover \(\widetilde{\operatorname {Diff}}^+(S^1)\) [ Her79 , Introduction (Remarque importante) ] . For Lie groups of diffeomorphisms in the locally convex setting see [ GN26 ] . In Mathlib, the monotone lifts with \(\varphi (x+1) = \varphi (x) + 1\) of circle maps appear as CircleDeg1Lift.
An orientation preserving diffeomorphism of the circle thus lifts to a diffeomorphism \(\varphi = \mathrm{id}+ u\) of \(\mathbb {R}\) with \(u \in C^\infty _{per}\) and \(\varphi ' = 1 + u' {\gt} 0\).
We let
and for \(u \in C^\infty _{per}\) we let \(\varphi _u = \mathrm{id}+ u\) be its lift.
The set \(\Omega \) is open and convex in \(C^\infty _{per}\), and contains \(0\). Hence \(\Omega \) is a manifold modeled on \(C^\infty _{per}\); since the model is complete, it is a Fréchet manifold. It is not a Banach manifold, since the model is not normable (an unformalized fact).
For \(u \in \Omega \), the continuous periodic function \(1 + u'\) attains a positive minimum \(c\) on the compact circle. If \(p_1(v - u) {\lt} c\), then \(1 + v' {\gt} 0\), so \(\Omega \) contains a neighbourhood of \(u\). Convexity is the identity \(1 + (au + bv)' = a(1 + u') + b(1 + v')\) for \(a, b \ge 0\), \(a + b = 1\). An open subset of a locally convex space is a manifold with the restricted identity chart.
For \(u \in \Omega \), the lift \(\varphi _u\) is an increasing homeomorphism of \(\mathbb {R}\), smooth with smooth inverse, and both \(\varphi _u\) and \(\varphi _u^{-1}\) commute with the translation by \(1\).
\(\varphi _u' = 1 + u' {\gt} 0\) gives strict monotonicity. Since \(u\) is bounded, \(\varphi _u(x) \to \pm \infty \) as \(x \to \pm \infty \), so \(\varphi _u\) is surjective by the intermediate value theorem. The inverse is smooth by the one-variable inverse function theorem, its derivative being \(1/\varphi _u' \circ \varphi _u^{-1}\).
Let \(u, w \in \Omega \). Then \(\varphi _u^{-1} = \mathrm{id}+ v\) with \(v \in \Omega \), and
The function \(v = \varphi _u^{-1} - \mathrm{id}\) is smooth and periodic by Proposition 18.25, and \((\varphi _u^{-1})'(y) = 1/\varphi _u'(\varphi _u^{-1}y) {\gt} 0\). For the composition, \(w + u \circ \varphi _w\) is smooth and periodic since \(\varphi _w\) commutes with the translation by \(1\), and by the chain rule \(1 + (w + u \circ \varphi _w)' = (1 + u' \circ \varphi _w)(1 + w') {\gt} 0\).
Conversely, \(\Omega \) captures all the diffeomorphisms of \(\mathbb {R}\) that commute with the translation by \(1\), and positivity of the derivative does not need to be assumed.
For \(u \in C^\infty _{per}\), \(u \in \Omega \) if and only if \(\varphi _u\) has a differentiable left inverse. Consequently, if \(\varphi \colon \mathbb {R}\to \mathbb {R}\) is smooth, has a differentiable left inverse and satisfies \(\varphi (x + 1) = \varphi (x) + 1\), then \(\varphi = \mathrm{id}+ u\) for a unique \(u \in \Omega \).
A continuous injective map of \(\mathbb {R}\) is strictly monotone, and it cannot be decreasing since it commutes with the translation by \(1\); so \(\varphi _u' \ge 0\), and the chain rule \(\psi '(\varphi _u x)\, \varphi _u'(x) = 1\) excludes zeros. For the second claim take \(u = \varphi - \mathrm{id}\), which is smooth and periodic; uniqueness is the injectivity of \(u \mapsto \mathrm{id}+ u\).
So \(\Omega \) is exactly the group of diffeomorphisms of \(\mathbb {R}\) commuting with the translation by \(1\), that is (by Remark 18.22), the universal cover of \(\operatorname {Diff}^+(S^1)\). Lifts of orientation reversing diffeomorphisms satisfy \(\varphi (x + 1) = \varphi (x) - 1\) instead, and they are excluded by the hypothesis.
Theorem 18.26 shows that \(\Omega \) is closed under composition and inversion, so it is a group, and Proposition 18.24 shows that it is a Fréchet manifold. The smoothness of the maps \(\Omega \times \Omega \to \Omega \), \((u, w) \mapsto w + u \circ \varphi _w\), and \(\Omega \to \Omega \), \(u \mapsto v\), is not proved here; this is what would make \(\Omega \) a Lie group, and it belongs to the Lie group phase of the project. We remark that no general inverse function theorem is available in Fréchet spaces, so the smoothness of the inversion has to be obtained by a direct argument.