5 Flows of vector fields
Integral curves and flows of smooth vector fields on manifolds modeled on Banach spaces: uniqueness, local flows, the maximal flow, the escape lemma and a completeness criterion, after Lang [ Lan99 , Ch. IV ] and [ GN26 , § 2.5 ] , and the real analytic case. Beyond Banach spaces even linear equations can have no solution, or more than one, so this chapter is restricted to Banach models.
5.1 Local flows on Banach manifolds
On manifolds modeled on locally convex spaces vector fields need not have local flows, nor unique integral curves [ GN26 , Examples 2.4.2 and 2.4.3 ] , so Theorem 8.39 assumes a local flow. On Hausdorff manifolds modeled on Banach spaces it exists, and Theorem 8.39 holds unconditionally.
Let \(M\) be modeled on a Banach space. If a curve \(c\) is continuous at \(t\) and \((\varphi _i \circ c)'(t) = \tilde X_i(\varphi _i(c(t)))\) in one chart \(i\) around \(c(t)\), then the same holds in every chart around \(c(t)\).
The chain rule for the transition map, which is Fréchet differentiable, and the change of charts law \(\tilde X_j \circ \tau = \mathrm{d}\tau \cdot \tilde X_i\) for \(\tau = \varphi _j \circ \varphi _i^{-1}\).
Let \(M\) be Hausdorff and modeled on a Banach space. Two integral curves of a smooth vector field on an open connected set \(I\) of times that agree at one instant agree on \(I\).
In a chart both curves solve \(c' = \tilde X_i \circ c\), whose right hand side is locally Lipschitz, so they agree near every instant where they meet; since \(M\) is Hausdorff the set of such instants is closed in \(I\).
Let \(M\) be Hausdorff and modeled on a Banach space, and \(X\) a smooth vector field. Around each point there are \(\varepsilon {\gt} 0\), an open set \(V\) and a smooth map \(\varphi \colon (-\varepsilon , \varepsilon ) \times V \to M\) whose curves \(t \mapsto \varphi (t, x)\) are integral curves with \(\varphi (0, x) = x\) (a flow box). Gluing chosen flow boxes gives an open set \(\Omega \supseteq \{ 0\} \times M\) of \(\mathbb {R} \times M\), whose slices \(\{ t : (t, x) \in \Omega \} \) are intervals, and a smooth map \(\mathrm{Fl} \colon \Omega \to M\) which is a local flow of \(X\) in the sense of Theorem 8.39, with \(\mathrm{Fl}(s + t, x) = \mathrm{Fl}(s, \mathrm{Fl}(t, x))\) whenever \((t, x)\), \((s, \mathrm{Fl}(t, x))\) and \((s + t, x)\) lie in \(\Omega \) [ GN26 , Corollary 2.5.21 ] , [ Lan99 , Theorem IV.2.2 ] .
In a chart, the local flows of lc-analysis (Fréchet \(C^{\infty }\) in time and initial value, from the Picard–Lindelöf theorem) give the flow boxes. By Theorem 5.2 two flow boxes agree where both are defined, so they glue to \(\mathrm{Fl}\) on the union \(\Omega \) of the boxes. The group law holds because \(s \mapsto \mathrm{Fl}(s + t, x)\) and \(s \mapsto \mathrm{Fl}(s, \mathrm{Fl}(t, x))\) are integral curves on an interval containing \(0\) and \(s\) with the same initial value. Here \(\Omega \) is not the maximal domain; see Theorem 5.4.
Let \(M\) be Hausdorff and modeled on a Banach space, and \(X\) a smooth vector field. The integral curves of \(X\) through \(x\) glue to a maximal integral curve \(t \mapsto \mathrm{Fl}(t, x)\), defined on an open interval \(J_x \ni 0\): every integral curve through \(x\) on an open interval \(I \ni 0\) is its restriction to \(I\). Let \(D = \{ (t, x) : t \in J_x\} \). Then:
(group law) if \(t \in J_x\), then \(J_{\mathrm{Fl}(t, x)} = J_x - t\), and \(\mathrm{Fl}(s + t, x) = \mathrm{Fl}(s, \mathrm{Fl}(t, x))\) whenever \((t, x) \in D\) and \((s, \mathrm{Fl}(t, x)) \in D\), in which case \((s + t, x) \in D\);
\(D\) is open in \(\mathbb {R} \times M\) and \(\mathrm{Fl}\) is smooth on \(D\);
\(\mathrm{Fl}\) is a local flow of \(X\) on \(D\), so \(\frac{\mathrm{d}}{\mathrm{d}t}\big|_{t=0} \mathrm{Fl}_t^*\omega = L_X\omega \) (Theorem 8.39) holds for it;
the flow of Theorem 5.3 is the restriction of \(\mathrm{Fl}\) to its domain \(\Omega \subseteq D\).
Maximality and the group law follow from uniqueness, as in [ Lan99 , Theorem IV.2.2 ] . For openness and smoothness we follow [ Lan99 , Theorem IV.2.6 ] and [ GN26 , Theorem 2.5.18 ] : for a fixed \(x_0\), the set of \(t \in J_{x_0}\) around which \(D\) contains a neighborhood of \((t, x_0)\) on which \(\mathrm{Fl}\) is smooth is open, contains \(0\), and is closed in \(J_{x_0}\), because near \(t\) the flow is \(\mathrm{Fl}(\tau , x) = \varphi (\tau - t_1, \mathrm{Fl}(t_1, x))\) for a flow box \(\varphi \) at \(\mathrm{Fl}(t, x_0)\) and \(t_1\) close to \(t\). No compactness argument is needed.
If the forward maximal time \(b = \sup J_x\) is finite, then \(t \mapsto \mathrm{Fl}(t, x)\) has no cluster point as \(t \to b^-\); in particular it eventually leaves every compact set. The same holds backwards.
If \(q\) were a cluster point, a flow box at \(q\) with time \(\varepsilon \) would extend the integral curve beyond \(b\) from a time \(t_1 {\gt} b - \varepsilon \) at which the curve is in the box, against maximality. Lang argues with sequences; since \(M\) need not be first countable we use cluster points of filters. We do not claim this argument is new.
Completeness of the model gives the flow boxes and local uniqueness; on manifolds modeled on Fréchet spaces smooth vector fields need neither have integral curves nor unique ones [ GN26 , Examples 2.4.2 and 2.4.3 ] . The Hausdorff property is needed: on the line with two origins the constant field \(\partial /\partial t\) has two integral curves through \(-1\) which agree up to time \(1\) and then split, so there is no maximal integral curve.
Let \(M\) be a Hausdorff real analytic manifold modeled on a real Banach space and \(X\) a vector field whose local representatives in the charts of the atlas are real analytic. Then \(X\) has real analytic flow boxes around every point, and the maximal flow \(\mathrm{Fl} \colon D \to M\) is real analytic on its open domain \(D \subseteq \mathbb {R} \times M\).
The flow boxes are the real analytic local flows of the local representatives on Banach spaces (lc-analysis, after [ GN26 , Theorem 2.4.34 ] ), read in a chart; charts and their inverses are real analytic. Then argue as for Theorem 5.4, following [ GN26 , Theorem 2.5.18 ] : the times \(t \in J_{x_0}\) near which the flow is real analytic form an open subset of \(J_{x_0}\) containing \(0\), closed in \(J_{x_0}\) because near \(t\) the flow is \(\mathrm{Fl}(\tau , x) = \varphi (\tau - t_1, \mathrm{Fl}(t_1, x))\) for a real analytic flow box \(\varphi \), and compositions of real analytic maps are real analytic.
Let \(X\) be a smooth vector field on a Hausdorff manifold \(M\) modeled on a Banach space \(E\), and let \(a {\gt} 0\) and \(K\) be such that every \(x \in M\) admits a chart \(\varphi \) at \(x\) whose target contains the ball \(B(\varphi (x), a)\), on which the local representative of \(X\) is bounded by \(K\). Then \(J_x \supseteq (-a/(K+1), a/(K+1))\) for every \(x\), and the maximal flow of \(X\) is defined on all of \(\mathbb {R} \times M\).
Fix \(x\) and \(\delta = a/(K+1)\). As long as the maximal curve stays in the ball, its representative \(\gamma = \varphi \circ \mathrm{Fl}(\cdot , x)\) is \(K\)-Lipschitz, so \(\| \gamma (t) - \varphi (x)\| \le K\delta {\lt} a\) for \(|t| {\lt} \delta \). A connectedness argument on \((-\delta , \delta )\) shows that the curve is defined and stays in the ball there: at a limit time \(t\) the representative is Cauchy, so it converges (here \(E\) is complete) to a point of the ball, whose preimage is a cluster point of the curve; by the escape lemma, \(t \in J_x\). Then the group law gives \(J_x + (-\delta , \delta ) \subseteq J_x\), so \(J_x = \mathbb {R}\). Lang deduces the uniform existence time from the local existence theorem with explicit constants [ Lan99 , Proposition IV.1.1 ] , which uses a Lipschitz constant and hence a bound on the derivative of the local representative; this argument does not need it. We do not claim it is new. The uniform radius \(a\) cannot be dropped: the constant field \(1\) on the interval \((0, 1)\) is bounded but not complete.