10 Differential equations
Differential equations are where the Banach and the locally convex settings part ways. On a Banach space the classical theory holds: local solutions exist, are unique, and depend smoothly (or analytically) on time and initial value. On a Fréchet space even linear equations with continuous coefficients may have no solution, or more than one (Chapter 16). What survives is the case in which the state space is a Banach space and only the parameters live in a locally convex space; this is the case treated in [ GN26 , § § 2.4–2.5 ] .
We first treat the second order equation of a quadratic spray, which is what the geodesics of lc-manifolds need, then local flows of vector fields on Banach spaces with \(C^{n}\), holomorphic and real analytic dependence, and finally equations with locally convex parameters and their maximal flows.
10.1 Quadratic second order equations
On a Banach space \(E\) we consider the equation of the geodesics of a spray,
where \(\Gamma \colon U \times E \times E \to E\) is \(C^{2}\) in the sense of Michal–Bastiani on an open set \(U \subseteq E\) and bilinear in the last two variables. It is equivalent to the first order system \((c, v)' = (v, \Gamma (c)(v, v))\), whose right hand side is Fréchet \(C^{1}\) (Theorem 8.1), hence locally Lipschitz.
Let \(E\) be a Banach space and \(x_0 \in U\). There is \(r {\gt} 0\) such that for every \(K \ge 0\) there is \(\varepsilon {\gt} 0\) for which every initial condition \(c(0) = y\), \(c'(0) = w\) with \(\| y - x_0\| \le r\) and \(\| w\| \le K\) has a solution on \([-\varepsilon , \varepsilon ]\) staying in \(U\).
The Picard–Lindelöf theorem, keeping track of the fact that the solution stays in the ball where the vector field is Lipschitz, gives a uniform time for \(\| w\| \le \delta \). If \(c\) is a solution, so is \(t \mapsto c(st)\), with initial velocity \(s\, c'(0)\); rescaling by \(s = (K + \delta )/\delta \) gives the statement.
Two solutions on \((a, b)\), staying in \(U\), with the same position and velocity at some \(t_0 \in (a, b)\), agree on \((a, b)\).
Integral curves of a locally Lipschitz autonomous field agree near every point where they meet (Grönwall); the set where they agree near \(t\) is open and closed in \((a, b)\).
10.2 Local flows on Banach spaces
Let \(E\) be a Banach space, \(U \subseteq E\) open and \(f \colon U \to E\) Fréchet \(C^{n}\), \(1 \le n \le \infty \). We prove that the solutions of \(c' = f \circ c\) depend in a \(C^{n}\) way on time and initial value, following the implicit function approach of [ Lan99 , Ch. IV, § 1 ] .
Let \(K\) be compact. If \(f\) is \(C^{n}\) on \(U\), then \(\gamma \mapsto f \circ \gamma \) is Fréchet \(C^{n}\) on the open set of curves \(\gamma \in C(K, E)\) with values in \(U\) (sup norm), with derivative \(\eta \mapsto (s \mapsto f'(\gamma (s))\, \eta (s))\).
The derivative comes from the mean value inequality and the uniform continuity of \(f'\) near the compact set \(\gamma (K)\) (compare [ Lan99 , Lemma IV.1.12 ] ). It is again a superposition operator, composed with a continuous bilinear map, so induction on \(n\) applies.
For \(x_0 \in U\) there are \(\varepsilon {\gt} 0\), an open \(V \ni x_0\) and \(\mathrm{Fl} \colon (-\varepsilon , \varepsilon ) \times V \to U\), jointly \(C^{n}\), with \(\mathrm{Fl}(0, x) = x\) and \(\partial _t \mathrm{Fl}(t, x) = f(\mathrm{Fl}(t, x))\). If \(f\) is smooth in the sense of Michal–Bastiani, so is \(\mathrm{Fl}\).
Let \(J\gamma (s) = \int _0^s \gamma \) on \(C([-1, 1], E)\) and \(\Psi (\lambda , x, \gamma ) = (\lambda , x, \gamma - x - \lambda J(f \circ \gamma ))\). By Lemma 10.3, \(\Psi \) is \(C^{n}\), and its derivative at \((0, x_0, x_0)\) is a shear, hence invertible. The inverse function theorem gives a \(C^{n}\) family \(\Gamma (\lambda , x)\) with \(\Gamma = x + \lambda J(f \circ \Gamma )\); put \(\mathrm{Fl}(t, x) = \Gamma (t, x)(1)\). By injectivity of \(\Psi \) near \((0, x_0, x_0)\), \(\Gamma (\sigma \lambda , x)(1) = \Gamma (\lambda , x)(\sigma )\) for \(|\sigma | \le 1\), and the fundamental theorem of calculus gives the equation. Lang applies the implicit mapping theorem only in \(x\), on a fixed short time interval [ Lan99 , Theorem IV.1.14 ] ; taking the time scale \(\lambda \) as a parameter gives joint smoothness directly. We do not claim this argument is new.
Let \(\mathbb {K} \in \{ \mathbb {R}, \mathbb {C}\} \), \(E\) a Banach space over \(\mathbb {K}\) and \(f\) of class \(C^{n}\) over \(\mathbb {K}\) on \(U\), \(1 \le n \le \infty \). For \(x_0 \in U\) there are \(\varepsilon {\gt} 0\), an open \(V \ni x_0\) and \(\mathrm{Fl} \colon B_{\mathbb {K}}(0, \varepsilon ) \times V \to U\), jointly \(C^{n}\) over \(\mathbb {K}\), with \(\mathrm{Fl}(0, x) = x\), whose restriction to real times solves \(\partial _t \mathrm{Fl}(t, x) = f(\mathrm{Fl}(t, x))\).
The proof of Theorem 10.4 works verbatim over \(\mathbb {K}\): the curves are parametrized by the real interval \([-1, 1]\) and only the time scale \(\lambda \) lies in \(\mathbb {K}\); Mathlib’s inverse function theorem holds over \(\mathbb {R}\) and \(\mathbb {C}\). The rescaling identity is used for real \(\sigma \) and real times. Theorem 10.4 is the case \(\mathbb {K} = \mathbb {R}\).
If \(f\) is complex differentiable on an open subset \(U\) of a complex Banach space, its local flows are complex differentiable in complex time and initial value. If \(f\) is real analytic on an open subset \(U\) of a real Banach space, its local flows \(\mathrm{Fl} \colon (-\varepsilon , \varepsilon ) \times V \to U\) are real analytic.
The holomorphic case is Theorem 10.5 for \(\mathbb {K} = \mathbb {C}\), since complex differentiable maps are \(C^{1}\) over \(\mathbb {C}\) (Theorem 9.9). In the real analytic case, let \(g\) be a complex analytic extension of \(f\) to an open subset of \(E_{\mathbb {C}}\), a complex Banach space with the norm of Lemma 9.19, and \(\Phi \) its holomorphic flow. For real \(t\) and \(x \in E\), \(t \mapsto \mathrm{Fl}(t, x)\) and \(t \mapsto \Phi (t, x)\) solve \(c' = g \circ c\) with \(c(0) = x\), since \(g\) extends \(f\); by uniqueness they agree. So \(\Phi \), composed with \((\mathbb {R} \times E)_{\mathbb {C}} \cong \mathbb {C} \times E_{\mathbb {C}}\), is a complex analytic extension of \(\mathrm{Fl}\). This is the proof of Glöckner and Neeb (real analytic case, p. 206), except that they show that complex solutions with real data stay real (their Lemma 2.4.30), while we use the real flow and uniqueness.
Let \(E\), \(\Lambda \) be real Banach spaces and \(f\) real analytic on an open subset \(U\) of \(\mathbb {R} \times E \times \Lambda \). Near every \(p_0 \in U\) the solution of \(c'(t) = f(t, c(t), \lambda )\) with \(c(t_0) = x\) is real analytic in \((t, t_0, x, \lambda )\).
Apply Theorem 10.6 to the real analytic field \((s, x, \lambda ) \mapsto (1, f(s, x, \lambda ), 0)\). Along its integral curves the first component has derivative \(1\) and the last one derivative \(0\), so the curve through \((t_0, x, \lambda )\) is \(t \mapsto (t_0 + t, c(t_0 + t), \lambda )\). Glöckner and Neeb allow any locally convex parameter space; that case is Theorem 10.11.
If \(f\) is \(C^{1}\) on \(U\), two solutions of \(c' = f \circ c\) on \((a, b)\) with values in \(U\) that agree at one instant agree on \((a, b)\).
\(f\) is locally Lipschitz; apply the argument of Theorem 10.2.
10.3 Parameters in locally convex spaces and maximal flows
Outside Banach spaces local existence and uniqueness can fail, even for continuous linear vector fields [ GN26 , Examples 2.4.2 and 2.4.3 ] .
Let \(f(p, x)\) be a family of \(\theta \)-contractions (\(\theta {\lt} 1\)) of a closed set of a Banach space \(F\), with \(p\) in an open subset of a topological vector space. The fixed point \(\varphi (p)\) is continuous, and if \(f\) is \(C^{1}\) so is \(\varphi \), with \(\mathrm{d}\varphi (p, q) = \sum _n A_p^n b_p(q)\), \(A_p = \mathrm{d}_2 f(p, \varphi (p))\), \(b_p = \mathrm{d}_1 f(p, \varphi (p))\). If \(f\) is \(C^{k}\), so is \(\varphi \).
Continuity from the uniform contraction estimate; the derivative is the Neumann series, whose terms converge locally uniformly (Tannery’s theorem). For \(C^{k}\), by induction on \(k\): differentiating \(\varphi (p) = f(p, \varphi (p))\), \(\mathrm{d}\varphi (p, q)\) is the fixed point of the uniform family of \(\theta \)-contractions \(w \mapsto \mathrm{d}f((p, \varphi (p)), (q, w))\) with parameter \((p, q)\), which is \(C^{k-1}\) by the induction hypothesis applied to \(\varphi \).
Let \(K\) be a compact metric space, \(\kappa \colon K \to \mathbb {R}\) continuous, and \(H\) a \(C^{k}\) map on an open subset of \(\mathbb {R} \times (E' \times Z)\) containing \(\kappa (K) \times \Omega \), \(E'\) normed. The operator \((\psi , z) \mapsto (s \mapsto H(\kappa (s), \psi (s), z))\) is \(C^{k}\) on the open set of \((\psi , z) \in C(K, E') \times Z\) with \((\psi (s), z) \in \Omega \) for all \(s\).
The difference quotients converge uniformly in \(s\) by the mean value inequality. By induction on \(k\): the derivative is the superposition operator of \(\mathrm{d}H(\cdot , (0, \cdot ))\), read on \(C(K, E' \times E') \times (Z \times Z)\).
Let \(E\) be a complex Banach space, \(W\) a complex locally convex space and \(f\) complex analytic on an open subset of \(\mathbb {C} \times E \times W\). The solution \(\Phi (t, t_0, y_0, p)\) of \(y' = f(t, y, p)\), \(y(t_0) = y_0\), is complex analytic in all variables near any point. The same holds for real analytic \(f\) on \(\mathbb {R} \times E \times W\), \(E\) a real Banach space and \(W\) a real locally convex space, and if \(f\) is \(C^{k}\), \(k \ge 1\), the solution is \(C^{k}\) in all variables; if \(f\) is continuous and Lipschitz in \(y\), uniformly in the other variables near the point, the solution is continuous.
As in [ GN26 ] : \(\eta (\tau ) = \Phi (t_0 + \tau (t - t_0), \ldots ) - y_0\) is the fixed point of \(\eta \mapsto \int _0^{\tau } (t - t_0) f(t_0 + s(t - t_0), \eta (s) + y_0, p)\, ds\) on \(C([-1, 1], E)\), a uniform family of contractions, \(C^{1}\) by the superposition results; its differential is complex linear, and a real \(C^{1}\) map with complex linear differentials into a Banach space is complex analytic [ GN26 , Theorem 2.1.12 ] . The rescaling identity (2.107) gives the differential equation. In the real case, the complexified equation preserves the closed set of curves with values in the real subspace, so its fixed point is real for real data; this replaces [ GN26 , Lemma 2.4.30 ] . In the \(C^{k}\) case the map \(g\) is \(C^{k}\) by Lemma 10.10, hence so is its fixed point (Lemma 10.9); the construction is written once for \(\mathbb {K} \in \{ \mathbb {R}, \mathbb {C}\} \). For continuous \(f\), the bounds come from continuity and the Lipschitz condition, and \(\Phi (r) = y_0 + \int _{t_0}^r f(v, \Phi (v), p)\, dv\).
Let \(E\) be a real Banach space, \(W\) a topological space and \(f\) defined on \(U \subseteq \mathbb {R} \times E \times W\), locally Lipschitz in \(y\). Solutions of \(y' = f(t, y, p)\) on open intervals are unique and glue to maximal solutions; let \(\mathrm{Fl}(t, t_0, y_0, p)\) be the maximal flow, on its domain \(\Omega \). Then \(\mathrm{Fl}(t, t_2, \mathrm{Fl}(t_2, t_1, y_1, q), q) = \mathrm{Fl}(t, t_1, y_1, q)\). If the equation admits local flows of a regularity class (closed under restriction, gluing and the composition below), \(\Omega \) is open and \(\mathrm{Fl}\) has that regularity on it. In particular, if \(W\) is a real locally convex space and \(f\) is continuous and locally Lipschitz in \(y\) (with parameters), \(C^{k}\) (\(k \ge 1\)), smooth or real analytic on an open set \(U\), then \(\Omega \) is open and \(\mathrm{Fl}\) has the same regularity on \(\Omega \); if all solutions with initial data in \(J \times S\) exist on the open interval \(J\), \(\mathrm{Fl}\) is real analytic on \(J \times J \times S\).
Uniqueness on open intervals by connectedness, from local uniqueness (Gronwall). Globalization as in [ GN26 , Theorem 2.5.18 ] : given \((\tau , t_0, y_0, p) \in \Omega \), the set of times \(t_1\) near which \(\Omega \) is a neighbourhood and \(\mathrm{Fl}\) is regular contains \(t_0\) (a local flow) and is open and closed in the interval of the solution: near a limit point \(\theta \), with a regular \(t_2\) close to \(\theta \), \(\mathrm{Fl}(t, t_1, y_1, q) = \Phi _\theta (t, t_2, \mathrm{Fl}(t_2, t_1, y_1, q), q)\) for the local flow \(\Phi _\theta \) at \(\theta \). A real analytic \(f\) is \(C^{1}\) in \((t, y)\) for fixed \(p\), hence locally Lipschitz in \(y\), and admits real analytic local flows by Theorem 10.11; a \(C^{k}\) map, \(k \ge 1\), is locally Lipschitz in \(y\) by the continuity of \(\mathrm{d}f\), and admits \(C^{k}\) local flows by the same theorem; so does a continuous map with a local Lipschitz condition.