Michal–Bastiani calculus on locally convex spaces

17 Limitations of the Michal–Bastiani calculus

The Michal–Bastiani calculus is defined on arbitrary locally convex spaces, needs no completeness, and its smooth maps are continuous. The price is paid elsewhere: spaces of operators and of smooth maps carry several natural topologies, none of which makes evaluation continuous in infinite dimensions, and as a consequence the category of smooth maps is not cartesian closed. This chapter collects these caveats, explains why they are not a matter of completeness, and records the convention that we follow throughout to avoid them: operator-valued data are always required to be smooth jointly (in uncurried form), never as maps into a space of operators. Nothing in this chapter is formalized; it is here to explain the design.

Throughout, \(E\) and \(F\) are locally convex spaces over \(\mathbb {K} \in \{ \mathbb {R}, \mathbb {C}\} \), and \(\mathcal{L}(E, F)\) is the space of continuous linear maps.

17.1 Topologies on spaces of operators

Three topologies on \(\mathcal{L}(E, F)\) will appear, each one the topology of uniform convergence on a family of subsets of \(E\):

  • \(\mathcal{L}(E, F)_s\): uniform convergence on finite sets (pointwise convergence); on normed spaces this is the strong operator topology;

  • \(\mathcal{L}(E, F)_c\): uniform convergence on compact sets (the compact-open topology);

  • \(\mathcal{L}(E, F)_b\): uniform convergence on bounded sets; on normed spaces this is the operator norm topology, since it suffices to look at the unit ball.

Since finite sets are compact and compact sets are bounded, \(s \subseteq c \subseteq b\).

A word of caution on terminology: in operator theory “strong topology” means \(s\), while in the theory of locally convex spaces the “strong topology” (on a dual space, say) is \(b\).

Remark 17.1 \(s\) and \(c\) agree on equicontinuous sets
#

On an equicontinuous subset \(H \subseteq \mathcal{L}(E, F)\) (for normed \(E\), \(F\): a set bounded in operator norm) the topologies \(s\) and \(c\) coincide. Indeed, given a compact \(K \subseteq E\), a continuous seminorm \(q\) on \(F\) and \(\varepsilon {\gt} 0\), equicontinuity gives a \(0\)-neighborhood \(V\) with \(q(T v) {\lt} \varepsilon \) for \(T \in H\), \(v \in V\); covering \(K\) by finitely many translates \(x_i + V\) reduces uniform convergence on \(K\) to convergence at the finitely many points \(x_i\). In particular, for a Banach space \(E\), a sequence in \(\mathcal{L}(E, F)\) which converges in \(s\) is bounded in operator norm (uniform boundedness principle), hence converges in \(c\): on Banach spaces the two topologies can only be distinguished by nets.

Remark 17.2 \(c\) is strictly finer than \(s\) in infinite dimensions
#

If \(E\) is infinite-dimensional and \(F \ne 0\), then \(s \ne c\) on \(\mathcal{L}(E, F)\). It suffices to treat \(F = \mathbb {K}\), i.e. the dual \(E'\). Every \(s\)-neighborhood of \(0\) in \(E'\) contains the annihilator of a finite set \(\{ x_1, \dots , x_k\} \). If the polar \(K^\circ \) of a compact set \(K\) contained such an annihilator, then every \(f \in E'\) vanishing on the \(x_j\) would vanish on \(K\) (scale \(f\)), and by the Hahn–Banach theorem \(K\) would lie in the finite-dimensional span of the \(x_j\). A compact set not contained in any finite-dimensional subspace exists (for normed \(E\): \(\{ 0\} \cup \{ x_n / n\} \) with \(x_n\) linearly independent unit vectors), so \(K^\circ \) is a \(c\)-neighborhood of \(0\) which is not an \(s\)-neighborhood.

Example 17.3
#
  1. (Incomplete \(E\), sequences.) Let \(E = c_{00}\) be the space of finitely supported sequences with the supremum norm, and \(\varphi _n = n\, e_n^*\). For each \(x \in E\), \(\varphi _n(x) = 0\) for large \(n\), so \(\varphi _n \to 0\) in \(s\). On the compact set \(K = \{ 0\} \cup \{ e_m / m : m \ge 1\} \) we have \(\varphi _n(e_n / n) = 1\), so \(\varphi _n \not\to 0\) in \(c\). (By Remark 17.1, such a sequence cannot exist on a Banach space.)

  2. (\(E = \ell ^2\), nets.) Let \(A = \{ \sqrt{n}\, e_n^* : n \ge 1\} \subseteq (\ell ^2)'\). Then \(0\) lies in the \(s\)-closure of \(A\): otherwise there would be \(x^{(1)}, \dots , x^{(k)} \in \ell ^2\) and \(\varepsilon {\gt} 0\) with \(\max _j \sqrt{n}\, |x^{(j)}_n| \ge \varepsilon \) for all \(n\), whence \(\sum _j |x^{(j)}_n|^2 \ge \varepsilon ^2 / n\), and summing over \(n\) gives a contradiction. But \(0\) is not in the \(c\)-closure of \(A\): on the compact set \(K = \{ 0\} \cup \{ e_m / \sqrt{m}\} \) each element of \(A\) takes the value \(1\).

For a Banach space \(E\), the topology \(c\) on \(E'\) is the bounded weak-\(*\) topology: the finest topology which agrees with the weak-\(*\) topology on bounded sets (Banach–Dieudonné theorem; for the statement on convex sets see [ FHHMPZ01 , Thm. 4.44 ] ).

17.2 The exponential law

For locally convex subsets \(U \subseteq E_1\) and \(V \subseteq E_2\) with dense interior, endow \(C^\infty (V, F)\) with the compact-open \(C^\infty \)-topology, and write \(f^\vee (x) = f(x, \cdot )\).

Theorem 17.4 [ GN26 , Thm. 1.7.30, Cor. 1.7.35 ]
#

For all locally convex \(E_1\), \(E_2\), \(F\) and every \(f \in C^\infty (U \times V, F)\), the map \(f^\vee \colon U \to C^\infty (V, F)\) is smooth, and \(\Phi \colon C^\infty (U \times V, F) \to C^\infty (U, C^\infty (V, F))\), \(f \mapsto f^\vee \), is linear and a topological embedding. If moreover \(V\) is locally compact, or \(U \times V \times E_1 \times E_2\) is a \(k_{\mathbb {R}}\)-space, then \(\Phi \) is an isomorphism of topological vector spaces.

Remark 17.5 Completeness plays no role
#

No completeness is assumed in Theorem 17.4. The hypothesis for the converse direction is topological: a \(k_{\mathbb {R}}\)-space is a Hausdorff space on which a real function is continuous as soon as its restrictions to compact sets are [ GN26 , Rem. A.6.15 ] . It holds when \(E_1\) and \(E_2\) are metrizable (normed spaces, complete or not; Fréchet spaces), when \(V\) is finite-dimensional, and also for \(k_\omega \)-spaces such as countable direct limits of finite-dimensional spaces, e.g. \(\mathbb {R}^{(\mathbb {N})}\) [ GN26 , Rem. 4.1.22, Prop. A.7.20 ] . So the absence of a countable basis of \(0\)-neighborhoods only threatens the converse direction, and only for spaces which are not \(k_{\mathbb {R}}\)-spaces.

17.3 Evaluation and cartesian closedness

The category would be cartesian closed if \(C^\infty (V, F)\) were an object and the evaluation \(\varepsilon \colon C^\infty (V, F) \times V \to F\) were smooth. This holds when \(V\) is finite-dimensional: then \(\varepsilon \) is \(C^{\infty , \ell }\) [ GN26 , Lemma 1.7.25 ] . It fails in every infinite-dimensional case, and already at the linear level.

Proposition 17.6 Evaluation on the compact-open dual

If \(E\) is infinite-dimensional, the evaluation \(E'_c \times E \to \mathbb {K}\), \((f, x) \mapsto f(x)\), is not continuous. Consequently, for every open \(U \subseteq E\), the evaluation \(C^\infty (U, \mathbb {K}) \times U \to \mathbb {K}\) is not continuous for the compact-open \(C^\infty \)-topology.

Proof ▶

Suppose the evaluation is continuous at \((0, 0)\). Then there are a compact \(K \subseteq E\), \(\delta {\gt} 0\) and an absolutely convex \(0\)-neighborhood \(W \subseteq E\) with \(|f(x)| \le 1\) whenever \(\sup _K |f| \le \delta \) and \(x \in W\). By homogeneity, \(K^\circ \subseteq \delta ^{-1} W^\circ \), and by the bipolar theorem \(W \subseteq \overline{W} = W^{\circ \circ } \subseteq \delta ^{-1} K^{\circ \circ }\), where \(K^{\circ \circ }\) is the closed absolutely convex hull of \(K\). The absolutely convex hull of a precompact set is precompact, and so is its closure; hence \(E\) has a precompact \(0\)-neighborhood and is finite-dimensional.

For the second statement, the compact-open \(C^\infty \)-topology induces on \(E' \subseteq C^\infty (U, \mathbb {K})\) the topology of \(E'_c\) (for a linear map all derivatives of order \(\ge 1\) are \(f\) itself or zero), and continuity of the evaluation at \((0, x_0)\) would give continuity of \((f, h) \mapsto f(x_0 + h) - f(x_0) = f(h)\) at \((0, 0)\).

The proposition covers Banach and Hilbert spaces: there the evaluation \(\mathcal{L}(E, F)_b \times E \to F\) is continuous [ GN26 , Rem. 2.3.9 ] , but \(b\) is not the topology which the compact-open \(C^\infty \)-topology induces on operators. For non-normable \(E\) there is no way out at all: the evaluation \(\mathcal{L}(E) \times E \to E\) is discontinuous for every vector topology on \(\mathcal{L}(E)\) (Maissen [ Mai63 , Satz 1 ] , see also [ KM97 , p. 2 ] and the notes to Ch. 3 of [ GN26 ] ).

Remark 17.7 The convenient calculus
#

The convenient calculus of Frölicher, Kriegl and Michor [ KM97 ] is cartesian closed. It works on Mackey complete (\(c^\infty \)-complete) spaces, and this is where a completeness hypothesis enters. The price: the exponential law holds only as an isomorphism of bornological spaces (already for \(E_1 = E_2 = \mathbb {R}\), the map \(\Phi \) is discontinuous for the topologies of the convenient setting, see the notes to Ch. 1 of [ GN26 ] ), and convenient smooth maps need not be continuous. On Fréchet spaces both calculi have the same smooth maps.

17.4 The derivative as an operator-valued map

Let \(f \colon U \to F\) be \(C^{k}\) with \(k \ge 1\), \(U \subseteq E\) open.

  • Into \(\mathcal{L}(E, F)_c\), no hypotheses. The map \(x \mapsto \mathrm{d}f(x) \in \mathcal{L}(E, F)_c\) is \(C^{k-1}\), for arbitrary locally convex \(E\), \(F\): apply the first part of Theorem 17.4 to \(\mathrm{d}f\) and corestrict to the closed subspace \(\mathcal{L}(E, F) \subseteq C(E, F)\) (as in the proof of [ GN26 , Prop. 2.3.17(b) ] ). Dually, for fixed \(x\) the map \(C^\infty (U, F) \to \mathcal{L}(E, F)_c\), \(f \mapsto \mathrm{d}f(x)\), is continuous linear, directly from the definition of the compact-open \(C^\infty \)-topology.

  • Into \(\mathcal{L}(E, F)_b\), normed spaces. If \(E\), \(F\) are normed, a Michal–Bastiani \(C^{k+1}\) map is Fréchet \(C^{k}\) (Theorem 8.1): continuity of \(x \mapsto \mathrm{d}f(x)\) in operator norm costs one derivative, and nothing for smooth maps (Corollary 8.3). On the other hand, \(f \mapsto \mathrm{d}f(x)\) is not continuous from \(C^\infty (U, F)\) to \(\mathcal{L}(E, F)_b\) when \(E\) is infinite-dimensional, since on \(E'\) the compact-open \(C^\infty \)-topology is \(c \ne b\).

  • Non-normable spaces. By Maissen’s theorem, there is no vector topology on \(\mathcal{L}(E)\) making evaluation continuous, so no choice of topology turns the derivative into a well-behaved operator-valued map while keeping the chain rule continuous.

17.5 The convention adopted

To stay clear of all of the above, operator-valued data are always required to be smooth in uncurried form. A smooth family of projectors on an embedded submanifold \(X \subseteq F\) is a map \(E \colon X \times F \to F\), linear in the second variable, such that \((p, w) \mapsto E_p w\) is smooth in charts (LocallyConvex.Manifolds.ProjectorField); the Christoffel symbols of a connection are smooth as functions \((x, a, b) \mapsto \Gamma _x(a, b)\) of three variables (LocallyConvex.Manifolds.Connection). No topology on \(\mathcal{L}(F)\) is ever needed. On Banach spaces this loses nothing: by Corollary 8.3, \((x, w) \mapsto E_x w\) is then Fréchet smooth, hence so is \(x \mapsto E_x\) into \(\mathcal{L}(F)\) with the operator norm; the uncurried and the operator-norm notions of smoothness agree for \(C^\infty \) data.

The convention does have visible consequences on non-normable models: the dual bundle \(T^*M = \bigcup _x (T_x M)'\) carries in general no canonical vector bundle structure [ GN26 , notes to Ch. 3 ] , so \(1\)-forms are treated as smooth maps on \(TM\) which are linear on the fibres; and the adjoint action of a Lie group is handled as the smooth map \(G \times \mathfrak {g} \to \mathfrak {g}\), not as a map into \(\mathcal{L}(\mathfrak {g})\).

AI89

T. Ya. Azizov and I. S. Iokhvidov, Linear Operators in Spaces with an Indefinite Metric, Wiley, 1989.

Bas64

A. Bastiani, Applications différentiables et variétés différentiables de dimension infinie, J. Analyse Math. 13 (1964), 1–114, doi:10.1007/BF02786619.

Bog74

J. Bognár, Indefinite Inner Product Spaces, Ergebnisse der Mathematik und ihrer Grenzgebiete 78, Springer, 1974, doi:10.1007/978-3-642-65567-8.

BS71a

J. Bochnak and J. Siciak, Polynomials and multilinear mappings in topological vector-spaces, Studia Math. 39 (1971), 59–76, doi:10.4064/sm-39-1-59-76.

BS71b

J. Bochnak and J. Siciak, Analytic functions in topological vector-spaces, Studia Math. 39 (1971), 77–112, doi:10.4064/sm-39-1-77-112.

FHHMPZ01

M. Fabian, P. Habala, P. Hájek, V. Montesinos Santalucía, J. Pelant and V. Zizler, Functional Analysis and Infinite-Dimensional Geometry, CMS Books Math. 8, Springer, 2001, doi:10.1007/978-1-4757-3480-5.

GGH10

H. Glöckner, R. Gramlich and T. Hartnick, Final group topologies, Kac–Moody groups and Pontryagin duality, Israel J. Math. 177 (2010), 49–101, doi:10.1007/s11856-010-0038-5.

GN26

H. Glöckner and K.-H. Neeb, Infinite-Dimensional Lie Groups, book manuscript, 2026, arXiv:2602.12362.

Glo02

H. Glöckner, Infinite-dimensional Lie groups without completeness restrictions, in Geometry and Analysis on Finite- and Infinite-Dimensional Lie Groups, Banach Center Publ. 55 (2002), 43–59, doi:10.4064/bc55-0-3.

Ham82

R. S. Hamilton, The inverse function theorem of Nash and Moser, Bull. Amer. Math. Soc. 7 (1982), 65–222, doi:10.1090/S0273-0979-1982-15004-2.

Kel74

H. H. Keller, Differential Calculus in Locally Convex Spaces, Lecture Notes in Math. 417, Springer, 1974, doi:10.1007/BFb0070564.

KM97

A. Kriegl and P. W. Michor, The Convenient Setting of Global Analysis, Math. Surveys Monogr. 53, Amer. Math. Soc., 1997, doi:10.1090/surv/053.

Lan99

S. Lang, Fundamentals of Differential Geometry, Grad. Texts in Math. 191, Springer, 1999, doi:10.1007/978-1-4612-0541-8.

Mai63

B. Maissen, Über Topologien im Endomorphismenraum eines topologischen Vektorraumes, Math. Ann. 151 (1963), 283–285, doi:10.1007/BF01470820.

Mar72

J. E. Marsden, Darboux’s theorem fails for weak symplectic forms, Proc. Amer. Math. Soc. 32 (1972), 590–592, doi:10.1090/S0002-9939-1972-0293678-X.

Mic38

A. D. Michal, Differential calculus in linear topological spaces, Proc. Nat. Acad. Sci. USA 24 (1938), 340–342, doi:10.1073/pnas.24.8.340.

Mic80

P. W. Michor, Manifolds of Differentiable Mappings, Shiva Math. Series 3, 1980.

Mil84

J. Milnor, Remarks on infinite-dimensional Lie groups, in Relativity, Groups and Topology II (Les Houches, 1983), North-Holland, 1984, 1007–1057.

Muj86

J. Mujica, Complex Analysis in Banach Spaces, North-Holland Math. Stud. 120, North-Holland, 1986.

Nee06

K.-H. Neeb, Towards a Lie theory of locally convex groups, Jpn. J. Math. 1 (2006), 291–468, doi:10.1007/s11537-006-0606-y; arXiv:1501.06269.

Pen70

J.-P. Penot, Sur le théorème de Frobenius, Bull. Soc. Math. France 98 (1970), 47–80, doi:10.24033/bsmf.1694.

Wei69

A. Weinstein, Symplectic structures on Banach manifolds, Bull. Amer. Math. Soc. 75 (1969), 1040–1041, doi:10.1090/S0002-9904-1969-12353-0.

dMU21

L. de Moura and S. Ullrich, The Lean 4 theorem prover and programming language, CADE-28, LNCS 12699 (2021), 625–635, doi:10.1007/978-3-030-79876-5_37.

mC20

The mathlib Community, The Lean mathematical library, CPP 2020, 367–381, doi:10.1145/3372885.3373824.