14 Locally convex direct sums, direct limits and Silva spaces
Locally convex direct sums and direct limits, after [ GN26 , Appendix B.13 and Sections 2.7–2.8 ] . They are the tool for spaces of compactly supported functions and sections, fine box products of manifolds and manifolds of mappings on non-compact manifolds [ GN26 , Sections 4.3–4.4 ] .
14.1 Direct sums
For topological vector spaces \((E_j)_{j \in J}\), \(\bigoplus _j E_j\) is the space of finitely supported families with the box topology: the boxes \(\bigoplus _j V_j = \{ x \mid x_j \in V_j \text{ for all } j\} \), \(V_j\) a \(0\)-neighbourhood in \(E_j\), form a basis of \(0\)-neighbourhoods.
The box topology is a vector topology over any nontrivially normed field, locally convex and Hausdorff when the \(E_j\) are; boxes of open sets are open; coordinates and inclusions are continuous. For countable \(J\), an additive map from \(\bigoplus _j E_j\) to a topological group is continuous as soon as its restrictions to the summands are; hence the box topology is the locally convex direct sum topology of [ GN26 , (B.24) ] . Moreover \(\bigoplus _j (E_j \times F_j) \cong \bigoplus _j E_j \times \bigoplus _j F_j\) and, for any index sets, \(\bigoplus _{(i, j)} E_{ij} \cong \bigoplus _i \bigoplus _j E_{ij}\) [ GN26 , Lemma B.13.2(b) ] .
For the universal property, as in [ GN26 , Lemma B.13.2(a) ] : choose \(0\)-neighbourhoods \(Q_k\) with \(Q_{k+1} + Q_{k+1} \subseteq Q_k\) and an injection \(n \colon J \to \mathbb {N}\); the box of preimages of \(Q_{n_j + 1}\) is mapped into \(Q_0\), by induction on the support, adding the summand of least index first. For uncountable \(J\) the locally convex direct sum topology can be strictly finer than the box topology.
If \(F_j \subseteq E_j\) are subspaces, \(\bigoplus _j F_j\) carries the topology induced by \(\bigoplus _j E_j\). If the \(E_j\) are Hausdorff, every bounded subset of \(\bigoplus _j E_j\) lies in \(\bigoplus _{j \in J_0} E_j\) for a finite \(J_0 \subseteq J\), and \(\bigoplus _j E_j\) is complete (quasi-complete, sequentially complete, Mackey complete) if every \(E_j\) is.
The box of the sets \(V_j \cap F_j\) is the trace of the box of the \(V_j\). If a bounded set met infinitely many summands, at coordinates \(x_{j_k} \neq 0\), a box omitting \(k^{-1} x_{j_k}\) would not absorb it. For completeness, the coordinates of a Cauchy filter converge, and the limit has finite support by the same argument. Closed bounded sets, Cauchy sequences and Mackey–Cauchy sequences are bounded, hence lie in a finite partial sum, where convergence is coordinatewise; the coordinates converge in the factors.
Let \(f_j \colon U_j \to F_j\) be \(C^{k}\) (\(k \in \mathbb {N} \cup \{ \infty \} \)) on open sets \(U_j \subseteq E_j\), with \(f_j(0) = 0\) for all but finitely many \(j\). Then \(\bigoplus _j f_j \colon (x_j)_j \mapsto (f_j(x_j))_j\) is \(C^{k}\) on the open set \(\bigoplus _j U_j\), with \(\mathrm{d}(\bigoplus _j f_j) = (\bigoplus _j \mathrm{d}f_j) \circ \Phi \). If each \(f_j\) is real analytic and \(0 \in U_j\) for all but finitely many \(j\), then \(\bigoplus _j f_j\) is real analytic.
Induction on \(k\), as in [ GN26 ] : the difference quotients of \(\bigoplus _j f_j\) only involve finitely many coordinates. In the real analytic case \(\bigoplus _j \tilde f_j\), for complex analytic extensions \(\tilde f_j\), is smooth with complex linear differentials, hence complex analytic, and extends \(\bigoplus _j f_j\) through \((\bigoplus _j E_j)_{\mathbb {C}} \cong \bigoplus _j (E_j)_{\mathbb {C}}\).
14.2 Direct limits
Let \(S_n\) be subspaces of a real vector space \(V\), each with a vector topology. The seminorms of \(V\) whose restrictions to every \(S_n\) are continuous define the locally convex direct limit topology. The inclusions are continuous, a linear map to a locally convex space is continuous as soon as its restrictions to the \(S_n\) are, and an injective such map to a Hausdorff space makes the limit Hausdorff.
For the universal property, compose with the gauge seminorms of the target.
If a monotone family \((S_i)_{i \in I}\) of subspaces with continuous inclusions admits a cofinal sequence \((S_{i_n})_n\), then both have the same locally convex direct limit topology: apply the universal property in both directions.
Let the \(S_n\) cover \(V\).
A convex set \(U \ni 0\) is a \(0\)-neighbourhood of the direct limit if and only if \(U \cap S_n\) is a \(0\)-neighbourhood of \(S_n\) for every \(n\).
For an ascending sequence with continuous inclusions, a convex set is open if and only if its traces on the \(S_n\) are open.
For countably many steps, the summation map \(\bigoplus _n S_n \to V\) is an open quotient map; hence the sets \(\bigcup _n (W_0 + \cdots + W_n)\), \(W_n\) (open) \(0\)-neighbourhoods of \(S_n\), form a basis of (open) \(0\)-neighbourhoods.
If the \(S_n\) are barrelled, so is the direct limit.
(a) The gauge of \(U \cap (-U)\) is a seminorm on \(V\) whose restrictions to the \(S_n\) are continuous. (b) Translate to a point of \(U\) and apply (a). (c) The summation map is continuous by the universal property of the direct sum; on the quotient of the direct sum by its kernel, a locally convex space, the inclusions of the \(S_n\) are continuous, so the inverse of the induced bijection is continuous by the universal property of the direct limit. (d) A lower semicontinuous seminorm on the limit restricts to continuous seminorms on the steps.
Let \(j \colon F \to E\) be an injective linear topological embedding into a locally convex space. Every absolutely convex open set \(V \subseteq F\) is \(j^{-1}(Q)\) for an absolutely convex open set \(Q \subseteq E\).
As in [ GN26 ] , \(Q\) is the convex join of \(j(V)\) and an absolutely convex open \(0\)-neighbourhood \(W\) of \(E\) with \(j^{-1}(W) \subseteq V\). A point \(a\, j(v) + b w\) of \(Q\) has the open neighbourhood \(a\, j(v) + b W \subseteq Q\) if \(b {\gt} 0\), and \(j(v) = r^{-1} j(rv) + (1 - r^{-1}) \cdot 0\) with \(rv \in V\), \(r {\gt} 1\), otherwise.
Let \(S_0 \subseteq S_1 \subseteq \cdots \) be locally convex subspaces covering \(V\), each \(S_n\) carrying the topology induced by \(S_{n+1}\). Then:
the direct limit induces the given topology on each \(S_n\);
the direct limit is Hausdorff if the \(S_n\) are;
if each \(S_n\) is closed in \(S_{n+1}\), every bounded (compact) subset of the limit is contained, and bounded (compact), in some \(S_n\);
the direct limit is complete if the \(S_n\) are;
if each \(S_n\) is closed in \(S_{n+1}\), the direct limit is quasi-complete (sequentially complete, Mackey complete) if the \(S_n\) are.
(a) Extend an absolutely convex open \(0\)-neighbourhood of \(S_m\) step by step with Lemma 14.8 and take the union, a \(0\)-neighbourhood by Lemma 14.7. (b) follows from (a). (c) If a bounded set \(B\) met infinitely many differences \(S_{n+1} \setminus S_n\), at points \(x_n\), the extensions in (a) can be cut down so that \(x_n \notin (n+1) W\), and \(W\) does not absorb \(B\). (d) As in [ GN26 ] , a Cauchy filter concentrates near some \(S_m\): otherwise the convex hull of sets \(W_n \cap S_n\), with \(W_n\) shrinking \(0\)-neighbourhoods, contradicts the Cauchy property. The traces on \(S_m\) of the sets \(A + W\) then form a Cauchy filter on \(S_m\), by (a), whose limit is the limit of the filter. (e) Closed bounded sets, Cauchy sequences and Mackey–Cauchy sequences (together with their bounded set) are bounded, hence lie and are bounded in some \(S_n\), by (c); conclude with (a).
14.3 Silva spaces
A Silva system presenting a locally convex space \(E\) consists of continuous linear maps \(j_n \colon E_n \to E\) from locally convex spaces and compact operators \(u_n \colon E_n \to E_{n+1}\) with \(j_{n+1} \circ u_n = j_n\), such that the ranges of the \(j_n\) cover \(E\) and a convex set \(C \ni 0\) is a \(0\)-neighbourhood as soon as every \(j_n^{-1}(C)\) is. Silva spaces, locally convex direct limits of Banach spaces with compact inclusions, are the case of injective \(j_n\) (by Lemma 14.7).
Let \(E\) be presented by a Silva system.
A set \(O \subseteq E\) is open as soon as every \(j_n^{-1}(O)\) is open: the locally convex direct limit topology is the direct limit topology of the topological spaces \(E_n\). Hence a map from \(E\) to a topological space is continuous as soon as its composites with the \(j_n\) are, and \(E\) is Hausdorff if the \(E_n\) are \(T_1\) and the \(j_n\) injective.
Products of Silva systems are Silva systems.
For a Silva space with \(T_1\) sequential steps (for instance Banach spaces), compact subsets are contained, and compact, in some step; if moreover the steps have bounded \(0\)-neighbourhoods, bounded subsets are contained, and bounded, in some step, and they are relatively compact.
We do not follow the route of [ GN26 ] through direct limits of compactifying sequences and \(k_\omega \)-spaces (Corollary A.7.12, Proposition A.7.20). (a) Given \(x = j_m(y_0) \in O\), build compact sets \(K_i \subseteq E_{m+i}\) with \(j_{m+i}(K_i) \subseteq O\) and convex sets \(A_i \ni 0\) with \(x + A_i \subseteq j_{m+i}(K_i)\): if \(U_i\) is a convex \(0\)-neighbourhood of \(E_{m+i}\) with \(u_{m+i}(U_i)\) inside a compact set \(L_i\), take \(A_{i+1} = A_i + \varepsilon _i j_{m+i}(U_i)\) and \(K_{i+1} = u_{m+i}(K_i) + \varepsilon _i L_i\), with \(\varepsilon _i {\gt} 0\) so small that \(K_{i+1}\) is still mapped into \(O\), by compactness. The union of the \(A_i\) is a convex \(0\)-neighbourhood, and \(x\) plus it lies in \(O\). (b) A convex set \(C \ni 0\) contains \(\tfrac 12 C_1 \times \tfrac 12 C_2\), where \(C_1 \times \{ 0\} \) and \(\{ 0\} \times C_2\) are its traces on the factors. For compact regularity, the compact sets \(k L_p\) cover \(E\) and, by (a), detect closed sets; a compact set meeting the complements of all their finite unions would contain an infinite closed discrete set. Bounded regularity and relative compactness then follow as in [ GN26 ] , with an increasing sequence of bounded \(0\)-neighbourhoods of the steps in place of normalized unit balls. We do not claim these arguments are new.
A barrelled Hausdorff locally convex space whose bounded sets are relatively compact is reflexive. Consequently, a Silva space with \(T_1\) sequential barrelled steps having bounded \(0\)-neighbourhoods (for instance Banach spaces) is a reflexive, complete \(k_\omega \)-space, and its strong dual is a Fréchet space.
A functional \(\varphi \) on the strong dual is bounded by \(1\) on the functionals bounded by \(1\) on a compact absolutely convex set \(C\). If no point of \(C\) matched \(\varphi \) on finitely many functionals \(f_1, \dots , f_k\), a functional on \(\mathbb {R}^k\) would separate \((\varphi (f_i))_i\) from the image of \(C\); compactness of \(C\) then gives a point matching \(\varphi \) everywhere. The evaluation map is continuous by Banach–Steinhaus and open by the bipolar argument (Hahn–Banach). For Silva spaces, the compact sets \(k L_p\) detect closed sets and absorb the compact sets, so \(E\) is \(k_\omega \); its topology is coherent with the bounded sets, so the strong dual is complete, and a sequence of compact sets absorbing the bounded sets makes it metrizable. The strong bidual of a metrizable space is complete, so \(E\) is complete. We do not claim this argument is new.
Let \(E\) be presented by a Silva system with Hausdorff steps and \(U \subseteq E\) open. A map \(f \colon U \to F\) to a Hausdorff locally convex space is \(C^{k}\) as soon as every \(f \circ j_n\) is \(C^{k}\) on \(j_n^{-1}(U)\). In a Silva space, the union of ascending open subsets \(U_n\) of the steps is open, and a map on it is \(C^{k}\) as soon as its restrictions to the \(U_n\) are.